The issues might have sent a group of adults into a frenzied argument: immigration and open borders; right-to-work laws and whether they do more harm than good; unions; and the idea of parents forcing their beliefs on their children.
But instead of tense quarrels exacerbated by a polarizing political climate, hundreds of high school students on Saturday approached the subjects in a calm, well-researched manner after spending most of this year’s speech and debate season refining their knowledge and opinions.
The Three Rivers Speech and Debate Tournament – one of the region’s largest – drew roughly 700 students, parents and teachers from Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia to Upper St. Clair on Friday and Saturday. It was the second year the event was hosted by the Upper St. Clair School District.
They competed in debate categories that included public forum, policy, parliamentary, extemporaneous, dramatic or humorous interpretation of literature, prose, poetry and more.
“It’s pretty cool that we’re organizing this tournament ... it takes a bunch of different kids from a bunch of different states and has them all competing,” Upper St. Clair senior Maanasa Reddy said. “It’s some pretty high-level tournaments.”

The tournament, which previously had been hosted by the North Hills and Bethel Park school districts, is an opportunity for students to not only hone their skills but to earn bids to state competitions and a national tournament hosted by the University of Kentucky in April.
“It’s one of the student organizations that gives kids real life skills,” said Ari Sobel, whose daughter is on the Upper St. Clair team. “For Gen Z to be tuned in to what’s going on in the world — because they have to be — gives you hope for the future.”
By Saturday afternoon, judges had whittled competitors down to the finalists. Hundreds of students milled about the high school cafeteria wearing their best business attire, finalizing speeches and preparing for upcoming rounds that would last into late afternoon.
Eventually, students began slowly inching toward classrooms where their events were held, met by parent volunteers acting as judges.
Julia Kelly and Annie McKliney, from the Ohio County School District in West Virginia, said Saturday’s competition was one of the biggest they’d attended so far.
“It’s crazy how many people are here,” said Ms. McKliney, a sophomore participating in extemporaneous speaking. “This is our biggest competition of the entire year. I personally had 40 competitors, so it’s pretty crazy. It’s a little nerve-wracking, but it’s fun.”
Ms. Kelly, a junior who participates in persuasive speech and poetry, said her team does most of its competing in the Pittsburgh area before participating at states in West Virginia.
She said she decided to join the team “to expand my speaking horizons because I’ve never really been a very extroverted person and I feel like it’s just something I can carry with me for the rest of my life. It’s just a good way to get comfortable speaking in front of people.”
Similarly, Harjote Kaur, a junior at Canfield High School in Ohio, said one-on-one debates allow her to pursue philosophy-based ideas and how they apply to real-world situations.
“I think it’s really interesting to study it and the practical real-world application of that,” Ms. Kaur said. “That’s mostly what got me into it, other than the fact that in the future I want to pursue a career in which you advocate for the less well-off.”
Addison Seeley and Ellen McDaniel, both sophomores at Jackson High School in Ohio, were able to choose their topics for program oral interpretation ahead of the event.
Ms. Seeley spoke on the idea of adults forcing their belief systems on kids. Ms. McDaniel decided to talk about sleep paralysis and dreams.
“It’s cool to get to educate on something I care about,” Ms. McDaniel said.
For Ms. Reddy, the Upper St. Clair senior, the event gave her the opportunity to look back on where she started in debate and how she had moved into original oratory.
“You’re seeing pretty much the best of the best, and so it’s really exciting to see new speeches, new people, new competitors that otherwise you probably would not have seen because they’re from a different state or from a different region of Pennsylvania,” Ms. Reddy said.
Ben Edwards, the Upper St. Clair head coach, said the tournament was not only special because it gave students a chance to move on to larger competitions, but also because it highlighted the Upper St. Clair community and school district.
Mr. Edwards, who teaches history and economics at the high school, noted that through the event, community members were able to explore classrooms and spaces they wouldn’t typically have access to.
And it provided a competitive space for students to express themselves.
“There’s an original oratory inside of everyone, there’s somebody who loves current events, there’s some kid who’s in a class who’s not able to express themselves in a competitive way,” Mr. Edwards said.
“All the competition is really for, honestly, athletes and stuff. This is a way that a completely different kind of kid can get exposed to not only competition and feeling good about themselves that way but really hone incredibly important skills.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.