At a town hall meeting Wednesday, some North Hills School District employees, alumni and residents said the “Indian” mascot is offensive and should be dropped, while others believe the more than 80-year-old moniker is a symbol of pride that should be kept.
About 120 people attended Wednesday night’s meeting about the issue. Although more than 140 signed up to speak, only about 60 ultimately voiced their opinions to the school board. No vote was taken, and school board members did not speak or answer questions. Speakers were about evenly split on the issue.
“We’re here tonight to face the fundamental question of how we want our children to see the world,” Valerie Aquila, of Ross Township, said.
Ms. Aquila said while she is excited for her oldest child to start kindergarten this year, Ms. Aquila is “very concerned that our children will be asked to praise and love a mascot that should be retired.”
“There should be change and it should be soon so that we can stop driving a wedge within our community and get back to the business of educating our children,” she said.
Wehonna Toth introduced herself as a Seneca and said she was speaking to represent one of the tribal nations.
Read More
“It is a little condescending to still see mascots that represent the so-called ‘Indian,’” she said. “I'm really disappointed that this is going on today and just as an educational institution, you guys do have an obligation to teach future generations and the history of this land and its Native people and that is how respect is generated towards Native people.”
Others in favor of changing the mascot, which dates back to as early as 1939, called it “outdated” and “offensive.”
Ryan Fleming said Native Americans are not a monolith despite depictions of the group relying on inaccurate stereotypes.
“Are we really honoring Native Americans by putting them on the same level with pirates, lions, tigers?” he asked. “If it would be a bad thing to have somebody who's dressed up as your mascot at a football game, then maybe it’s time to move on. It doesn't have to happen right away. Let the students decide to just like the students in the 40s were given the opportunity to do.”
The school’s mascot first elicited action from the school board after the high school’s marching band was unable to march in their regular uniforms at Walt Disney World because the garb included Native American imagery. Instead, the band marched in their away game uniforms. In April, the school board unanimously voted to purchase 250 new, redesigned uniforms for the band, costing around $186,000.
Money was at the forefront of concerns for speakers who spoke in favor of maintaining the mascot. According to a report by North Hills Superintendent Patrick Mannarino, estimated costs for a potential mascot rebrand were approaching $500,000.
Barbra Stull, who graduated from the district in 1958 and has been a longtime Ross Township resident, said she thinks “this is a misuse of our hard earned tax dollars.”
“Surely our hard earned money could be spent to enrich the curriculum and to provide safety measures for the school,” she said.
“No one, my former classmates, my family, ever have ever considered the term ‘Indian’ to be demeaning or derogatory” she continued. “Instead, we consider it a symbol of strength, courage, and bravery.”
Resident Jim Baker also recommended the money be used to address other issues.
“There are many other ways to spend this money,” he said. “For instance, we can make sure our students are at the best results possible in order to get a quality education. Also, I don't need to remind everyone of the violence disturbing our schools. This kind of money could be used in proactive to ensure that our schools, students and faculty or students are safe.”
Like Ms. Stull, Tom Wallace, a 1986 graduate and Ross Township resident, said he never saw the mascot as offensive.
“I don't understand why we're even here,” he said. “This wasn’t an issue for 93 years. Now all of a sudden it's an issue. I don't agree with it. When I went to North Hills, we were proud of that.”
Wednesday’s town hall adds North Hill School District to the list of Western Pennsylvania schools that face debates over the use of Native American names and imagery.
In April, Penn Hills School District held a town hall to solicit public input about its mascot, also the “Indian.” Seneca Valley School Board unanimously voted last year to discontinue its use of Native American imagery, though it retained its “Raiders” moniker, while Shady Side Academy’s athletics retired its former name and rebranded as the Bulldogs in 2020.
Erin Vecchio, Penn Hills school board president, said in an email that the board is “moving forward” on plans to hold a ballot referendum about the Penn Hills mascot.
“I think it should be up to the taxpayers to make the change, because they have to pay for it!” she wrote.
Some schools, however, have yet to follow suit. West Allegheny School District, like North Hills, continues to use the “Indian” name. Peters Township School District has also kept the same name, opting to replace its previous logo depicting a Native American with an arrowhead.
The National Congress of American Indians reported this year that almost 2,000 K-12 schools in the United States use Native American mascots.
Across the country, numerous schools and professional sports teams, including the Washington Commanders and Cleveland Guardians, have scrapped offensive or contentious names in the last few years.
Hannah Wyman: hwyman@post-gazette.com and Twitter @Hannah_SWyman. Post-Gazette news intern Alex Koller contributed to this story.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.