Community opinion remains split as the Pittsburgh school board contemplates a plan that would make masking optional for city students and staff members under current federal guidelines.

School board members will vote Wednesday on a plan that would align the district with recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that say masks do not need to be worn when the community level of COVID-19 is low or medium.

At a public comment session Monday evening, however, not everyone agreed that the district should end the universal indoor mask mandate that has been in place all year. While some said it was time for masking to end, others argued that the district is not prepared for the change.

“If you aren’t mandating that all students, teachers and staff be vaccinated, and you haven’t made any significant changes to the ventilation systems in the classrooms, I don’t see how you can begin to think about removing the masks,” said Lydia Blank, a parent of three city students.

Advertise with us

Even though the community level of COVID-19 in Allegheny County has been low since the CDC updated its guidance in February, Ms. Blank said that under the previous metrics the transmission rate in the county would be considered high. The new CDC recommendations take into account hospital capacity as a key measure in determining the threat that COVID-19 poses to a community.

The Pittsburgh Public Schools is one of the few districts in the area that still has a universal indoor mask mandate. A number of local school districts moved quickly to end their masking requirements after the CDC changed its guidelines earlier this year.

Some, including former city schools board member Moira Kaleida, said schools should not make policies using the same measurements as hospitals. They said that if health care systems become vulnerable, it will mean that COVID cases will have already increased significantly in the community and likely in schools.

Ms. Kaleida suggested that the board make masks optional when the community level is low, but then require students and staff to wear them again if the level reaches medium.

“Doing so will mitigate risks to our most vulnerable kids and staff while also allowing us to take off masks when our level is at low,” she said. “This is a commonsense approach and a happy medium that will allow the most children to receive their education and keep schools open.”

Advertise with us

Still, several commenters said the district should follow the CDC guidelines for a number of reasons, such as improving the delivery of instruction in language classes.

“Students in language classes miss out on lip reading to facilitate their articulation and pronunciation skills,” said Ellie Haizlett, a Spanish teacher at Allderdice High School. “They have trouble hearing the speaker, and students lack emotional feedback in the form of smiles and other nonverbal cues.”

Troy Taylor, another Allderdice teacher, said a growing number of students have to be told repeatedly to wear their masks properly. Students and staff members, he said, should be allowed to make their own decision whether or not to wear masks in schools, just like almost everywhere else they go.

“Presently, it just seems students are following a rule instead of following scientifically substantiated guidelines from our nation’s most trusted medical advisors,” Mr. Taylor said. “Everything that they use to structure guidelines is based exclusively on peer-reviewed publications and research.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.