Sewickley Academy students protest outside school

About 50 people, many of them students, gathered Friday morning outside of Sewickley Academy to protest recent programming and personnel decisions by the school's administration.

The group stood across the street from the school, holding signs and recounting a list of demands, including a request for the academy to take student voices seriously.

"This movement is because us, as students, are afraid at our school," said student Madeleine Wren. "We have been censored, and we will not put up with it. We now must protest peacefully to show the school that we need action."

The protest comes a day after police were called to the school as several parents and students attempted to deliver a petition to Head of School Ashley Birtwell.

Advertise with us

Students had circulated the petition after learning that the academy would not renew the contracts of two teachers the students viewed as their allies and following months of unrest at the school since the summer when six top administrators were fired. The firings, which included the academy’s director of diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice, led to questions about the school’s direction and commitment to those initiatives.

The petition, which the students said garnered more than 100 signatures, made eight demands of academy leaders, including conducting a national search for a new DEISJ director; monthly meetings between the board of trustees and students, parents and teachers; unbiased investigations before the removal of a teacher; and ending policies placed in the student handbook this year that allow the school to discipline students and families who criticize academy decisions.

The protesting students held signs with phrases including “Stop removing our support systems” and “Whose voices are being heard?” and read their list of demands to school staff and others who had gathered to watch them.

Classes were canceled for senior school students Friday because of the incident involving the police, but the students decided to hold the protest anyway.

"I thought the crowd was maybe going to be like five people and a few parents," said student Georgia Cox. "Seeing all these people here, it makes me really hopeful for the future."

Advertise with us

Not all students at the school agreed with the protest, however.

Student Naomi Wigley said she could sense the tension at the school and accused the protesting group of causing chaos and making it hard for her and others to learn.

“A lot of the more conservative students for the past three to four weeks have been sitting back and almost laughing at this group because we never understood what their motive was,” she said. “But [after] yesterday, this is no longer something to laugh at. It’s become extremely serious.”

On Thursday, several parents and about a dozen students tried to deliver the petition to Ms. Birtwell. But the school said the group went about the delivery in an inappropriate and aggressive manner and that police needed to be called to ensure safety.

In a letter Ms. Birtwell sent to the community Thursday night, she said “academy staff attempted to manage the group in a calm manner and asked them to disperse, [but] the group refused to cooperate, and their disorderly conduct escalated.” Ms. Birtwell said Friday that the group hurled obscenities and had words targeting some staff members.

Advertise with us

Parents and students denied that they acted unruly and said they were just trying to have their voices heard.

Edgeworth police Chief John Burlett, who responded to the school, on Friday said he did not witness any disorderly behavior when he arrived at the scene Thursday.

“Everybody was peaceful, calm and obeyed orders to leave,” Chief Burlett said, noting that no arrests were made and no citations were issued.

During the incident, Assistant Head of School Ken Goleski told history teacher Gail Wolfe, who was with the group to support the students, that she was fired. On Friday, however, Ms. Birtwell appeared to indicate that the school didn’t officially dismiss Ms. Wolfe.

“I was not there personally, but what I can tell you is that no personnel decisions have been made to date, and we are currently looking into that with the appropriate parties,” Ms. Birtwell said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Birtwell said she has not contacted Ms. Wolfe since the incident and was not aware of any other school officials reaching out to her.

Still, Ms. Birtwell supported the students’ ability to protest and was among the school staff who went to watch the rally. Before going back inside, she praised the students for taking a stand.

Ms. Birtwell, who has served as interim head of school following the firing of longtime academy chief Kolia O’Connor over the summer and was named to the job permanently last month, said the school encourages rigorous debate, but it must be done in the right way.

She acknowledged that tensions had been growing at the school for months over some of the changes that were made under her leadership.

One of the main changes, she said, was giving students the ability to explore different viewpoints and debate ideas with teachers and classmates, which she said wasn’t happening under the school’s previous administration.

Advertise with us

“We felt that the school had become a political platform and that certain viewpoints were being more encouraged, that some students were feeling pressure to write papers in particular directions to get a particular grade,” she said. “That’s not healthy discourse. That’s not preparing students to be future leaders.”

Ms. Birtwell said, though, that political leanings had nothing to do with the recent dismissals of staff member and administrators.

“The school was known to have a particular political platform, and that’s what we need to be shifting away from,” she said “What’s most important for our kids is to be encouraged to be independent thinkers.”

Mr. O’Connor, who served as the head of school from 2003 until last summer, was viewed as more of a leader on issues involving race and DEISJ initiatives.

But Mr. O’Connor was fired about a month after an unaffiliated and anonymous group of academy parents sent a letter to school families and leaders expressing concerns about what it called political and ideological persuasion in the institution’s curriculum — a note that many in the community felt was threatening and had strong racial overtones.

Advertise with us

Five other administrators were fired a few weeks later, including LaVern Burton, the academy’s nationally respected DEISJ director. Ms. Birtwell has previously said the firings had to do with declining enrollment and ensuring the school was meeting its standards of academic excellence.

Another one of the administrators, Douglas Leek, was in his first year as the academy’s director of admissions and financial aid. He filed a federal lawsuit against the school alleging racial discrimination and settled for an undisclosed amount in October. Mr. Leek is Black and was replaced by a white woman.

The Pennsylvania Association of Independent Schools has opened multiple investigations into the school because of complaints from parents and faculty members over the firings and environment at the school.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.