A third Pennsylvania state-owned university wants to lower tuition by returning to the standard flat rate for full-time in-state undergraduates, after experiments including per-credit pricing generated mixed results, officials said.

East Stroudsburg University is joining Indiana University of Pennsylvania in proposing a return to the flat $7,716 yearly rate for full-time Pennsylvanians.

Both plans are on the agenda for a special State System of Higher Education board of governors meeting Wednesday, during which a new name for three merged universities in the northeast — Bloomsburg, Lock Haven and Mansfield universities — may be revealed. The meeting at 4:30 p.m. will be held via Zoom.

Earlier, in 2018, Mansfield went back to the system’s base full-time tuition after failed experiments yielded so many tuition prices there — up to 34 — that leaders said students, parents and admissions staffers were confused.

Advertise with us

"While families understand the concept of one tuition price and different scholarship amounts, it is more difficult for an admissions officer to explain many different tuition rates for the same educational product, with fewer scholarships,” Mansfield officials said at the time in asking the system board for the change.

The pricing experiments took hold on several State System campuses about seven years ago under then-Chancellor Frank Brogan, as financially strapped schools sought new flexibility to lower and increase prices depending on varied regional student markets, differing costs to deliver academic programs and a decadeslong history of tepid state funding support.

Of late, State System leaders including Chancellor Daniel Greenstein have expressed a renewed push for affordability, saying tuition and other fee increases the last 20 years have priced out of the market many middle- and low-income students, for which the nearly four-decade-old system was created by the Legislature to serve.

Gov. Tom Wolf's proposed Commonwealth budget for 2022-23 includes a historic funding increase from $477 million to $552 million for the State System.

That increase would be dramatic, but as Mr. Greenstein told the state Legislature last year, it would only bring the 14-campus State System closer to average in terms of what other states provide their public universities. Pennsylvania currently ranks 47th our of 50 in per-capita funding.

Advertise with us

"To really flood the system the way that it was and to continue to enable us to offer the significantly more affordable level of education that we offered 15 and 20 years ago, we're looking at $700 million a year," the chancellor said. "Just to be clear, $650 million, $700 million a year does not bring Pennsylvania to the top of the league table in terms of investment in higher education. It gets us halfway there."

The State System enrolls nearly 89,000 students, and like other regional public university systems, is well below peak enrollment for reasons including fewer high school graduates and price. The system’s student headcount was nearly 120,000 students in 2010.

Three other Western Pennsylvania system campuses — California, Clarion and Edinboro universities — also are being merged under the name Pennsylvania Western University, or Penn West. The six combined western and northeastern campuses are due to enroll their first students in August.

In 2016 and 2018, IUP and East Stroudsburg, respectively, instituted pricing pilot programs that charge in-state undergraduate tuition at a different rate than the standard in-state tuition rate. "Both have determined it is in the best interest of their students to eliminate the programs and return to the standard in-state tuition rates," according to material accompanying the State System's meeting agenda for Wednesday.

In fall 2018, East Stroudsburg instituted what it called the Warrior Promise Guaranteed Tuition Program, pledging a fixed tuition rate of $8,228 for four years, pegged to what had been yearly tuition increases averaging 7.4% the previous five years.

Advertise with us

“The Warrior Promise was designed to provide several benefits, including elimination of tuition inflation, predictability in tuition rates and fees, and an incentive to complete degrees in four years, thus reducing students’ debt burden," according to State System agenda materials.

But the State System froze its tuition the next three years at $7,716, and could be headed for a fourth consecutive year, meaning East Stroudsburg students pay more than other students.

This action changed the primary premise on which the Warrior Promise was based

At IUP, the university switched from the system's $7,716 flat tuition for students taking 12 to 18 credits a year to a per-credit price system that increased the published price for most students. The university boosted scholarship aid and discounted the per-credit total by descending amounts, fixing at a 1% discount since 2018.

"IUP’s goal in returning to the standard, banded tuition structure is to have a positive impact on student success.

Advertise with us

“During the timeframe of the per credit pricing, IUP has experienced declining enrollment and market share, lower yields from admissions to enrollment, lower credit-taking patterns by students, and declining persistence and retention," according to to the board agenda's back up material.

Last month, the return to flat pricing for full-time students could yield savings of about 20% for some students, campus leaders said.

A number of price experiments that have raised and lowered tuition and fees based on program demand and student demographics continue. Millersville and Shippensburg universities also continue to charge per-credit pricing for full-time undergraduates.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter @Bschackner