Matters briefly got out of hand near the steps of Old Main at Penn State University in August as a counter-protester darted through 100-plus students and faculty who were rallying for a vaccine mandate there.

Tempers flared and a scuffle ensued. When it was over, the counter-protester in an orange vest carrying a large sign and shouting toward the crowd had a bloodied face, and an assistant professor at Penn State would face misdemeanor charges including simple assault.

Five months later, Oliver Baker, the assistant professor of English and African American studies, has been acquitted of the last of those charges — a summary harassment complaint by university police. Two other misdemeanor charges, simple assault and disorderly conduct, were dropped earlier.

Nevertheless, Penn State appears poised to fire Mr. Baker anyway, his supporters say. That is drawing the ire of groups including the Penn State chapter of the American Association of University Professors, and nearly 1,000 individuals who so far have signed a petition demanding his reinstatement.

Advertise with us

(Warning: Explicit language)

They say the professor simply stepped up on Aug. 27 to defend against an aggressive intruder who was intimidating rallygoers.

“We are therefore shocked to learn that, rather than accept Professor Baker’s acquittal, the University has initiated an AC70 dismissal procedure against him on the grounds that he is guilty of “grave misconduct,” read a statement from the AAUP. “A faculty member cannot be guilty of grave misconduct if he has committed no misconduct of any kind.”

The statement added, “This decision sends a chilling message to all University faculty: that they can be brought up for dismissal by an unaccountable Human Resources office that has ignored a faculty member’s exoneration by a court of law.”

“We are aware of the argument that Professor Baker should have alerted police rather than attempt to reason with the counter-protestor himself. (Indeed, at trial the counter-protestor testified that Professor Baker simply asked to accompany him to the periphery of the rally in order to listen and talk.).” the statement continued. “But these are volatile times, and many rally attendees had legitimate reason to fear violence.”

Advertise with us

Penn State officials did not comment Tuesday on the AAUP letter, dated last Thursday, the potential grounds for dismissal or the policy upon which it is based.

“Oliver Baker remains on administrative leave while internal university processes, which are considered confidential, continue,” Penn State spokeswoman Lisa Powers said Tuesday. “Given this is a personnel matter, we have no additional information to share.”

Mr. Baker did not respond to requests for comment, nor did his attorney, Julian Allatt.

The counter-protester, Avi Rachlin, 20, a junior business management major, told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Wednesday that he sees it differently. He said he is not facing university discipline, was standing up for a principle and cut through the rally crowd because he was being “stalked” by rallygoers.

He is founder of a group called the “Penn State Resistance” and says he is not vaccinated. He says he initially took issue with mandates but later questioned the vaccine’s efficacy.

Advertise with us

“I think he [Mr. Baker] realizes that what he did was wrong and inappropriate as a professor,” remarked Mr. Rachlin, who said he is from New Jersey but declined to specify the town. “I believe he let his emotions get the best of him.”

The online petition asserts that Mr. Baker’s values track closely with the values of the state’s flagship public university, where he is employed.

Mr. Baker “is beloved by his students for his teaching and mentoring. He is beloved by the community for his work in supporting and defending vulnerable members of our community in the throes of a global pandemic and beyond,” it read. “Dr. Baker is a prime example of Penn State’s commitments to social justice, diversity and service to the university and his community.’’

Last summer, tensions already were escalating at Penn State and elsewhere when rallygoers gathered near the front steps of Old Main, a landmark building dating to the 1850s on the main University Park campus.

In Pennsylvania and other states, debates have raged over whether public universities had the right to require students and employees to take the COVID-19 vaccine to combat the virus. The issue, like much else about COVID-19, appeared to turn on public health and political ideology.

Advertise with us

At Penn State, Mr. Rachlin waved a large placard with the word “LIBERAL” as he waded into the rally crowd and saw others pulling it away.

The Centre Daily Times reported on the initial charges against Mr. Baker and their ultimate disposition. It also shared in its coverage a video on social media showing the encounter, which was from Centre County Report, produced by the school of communications at Penn State. Another video was tweeted by a CDT reporter.

The Coalition for a Just University, which was involved in the Aug. 27 rally, issued its own statement praising the decision by the Centre County District Attorney’s office for dropping the case, while expressing concern about Penn State’s apparent decision to continue pursuing potential dismissal of Mr. Baker. Officials with that group did not return a request for comment.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter @Bschackner