The West Mifflin Area School Board is debating whether to repair or replace an electronic marquee at the high school that was damaged by a recent lightning strike.

The board on Sept. 23 rejected a bid to replace it, with board members Bill Bennett, Judith Ahern, Debbie Kostelnik, Gina Englert and Erin O’Leary-White opposed, and Jonathan Mattis, Nicholas Alexandroff, Matt Blazevich and Anthony DiCenzo in favor.

The board received a proposal from Nevco, Inc., which makes electronic signs, to replace the marquee at a cost not to exceed $88,542. After insurance, the net cost to replace the marquee would have been $72,232, which would have been paid for out of the district’s construction budget.

Prior to the vote, some residents spoke.

Advertise with us

“Why is it necessary to go for this?” said resident Mark Donahoe, who said a lot of people in the district are talking about the marquee. “It seems like a lot of money if you can have insurance take care of it.”

“Why exactly do we need a marquee?” questioned parent Brian Mach.

Mr. DiCenzo, who voted in favor or replacing the marquee, said “obviously it’s a sensitive subject.”

He said the sign is outdated at about 10 to 12 years old. it’s out of warranty and the insurance company would have paid about $17,000 toward the cost of a new sign.

“Yes, spending $500 to repair it seems very simple, and why would anyone think to do anything otherwise,” Mr. DiCenzo said. But, he went on to say that the board is running the risk of having to replace it in the near future.

Advertise with us

“We have an opportunity now to use the $17,000 that the insurance company will give us to offset the cost of a new board. We will lose that and will forfeit that by simply just repairing it,” Mr. DiCenzo said.

District business manager Joseph Esper said the first check from the insurance company was for $10,600, but if the district chose to replace the marquee, they would send another $5,500.

Board president Mr. Blazevich said the board needs to further discuss the matter and how to go about repairing it.

“I think we need to talk about it. I don’t think we made a decision to repair it. I think we just did not vote to replace it,” Mr. Blazevich said.

A motion was made by Ms. Englert to have the district’s business office put out a bid for repairs to the marquee. That motion was then tabled.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.