Masks will be optional in the Mars Area School District this year unless the state mandates that masks be worn.

Superintendent Mark Gross reiterated the policy during Tuesday’s board meeting, saying that the district’s solicitor does not believe that they can legally require masks without a state mandate.

“We’re not sitting around being totally ignorant to the fact that this is a hot bed issue. We look at the statistics every day,” Mr. Gross said. “It is easy for those folks to recommend, but it is very difficult for this board and myself to implement anything that we are not 100% sure we have the authority to implement.”

Butler County Community College is mandating masks, as is neighboring district Pine-Richland in Allegheny County. Both Allegheny and Butler counties are currently in the “high” level of COVID-19 transmission, the highest possible level.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gross noted that 75% of parents who participated in a district survey were against a mask mandate.

“If it’s a local choice for districts, it should be a parental choice,” he said. “If we are provided a mandate or an emergency order, this district is not stubborn. We will comply.”

Mr. Gross said that the district will not require a masked child to quarantine if in contact with an infected classmate.

Several residents spoke on the issue, with mask proponents, including a physician and an intensive care nurse, expressing concern about the contagiousness of the delta variant. Mask opponents spoke about parental choice, the lack of mask efficacy and freedom, with one unidentified man saying “my body, my choice” after a pro-mask speaker.

“If you can prove to me that a mask works, then tell me so,” said Garry Lazar. “These kids have to grow up in this school and this is their identity, for people to see their faces, not see a mask. We’re not Muslims. We’re Americans. We’re patriots.”

Advertise with us

His wife, Kathy, said masks are “physiologically and psychologically abusive.”

“If you watch alternative news, you’ll get the facts. I feel sorry for everybody who is so afraid that they will mask their kids out of fear,” she said.

Teresa Rose, a nurse in an intensive care unit, said her immune compromised son may have to go to a different school if masks are not mandated in Mars Area.

“How can I send him into a room with unmasked children? He can wear a mask, but will not be protected,” she said. “Please allow my children to get an education this year. This is where I want them to be, but I cannot send them here like this.”

Mrs. Rose also chided board members for their reactions to speakers with whom they do not agree. “This has been disgusting to me to see the eye rolling, the looks when people are coming here asking you to make a good decision for their children.”

Advertise with us

Parent Tara Bartolomucci said that one child carrying the delta variant can infect as many as seven others. If there is an outbreak among unvaccinated children, a large number could be sent home to quarantine, she said.

“You will have 100% of the parents upset if you have students quarantining at home and schools closed for cleaning,” she said.

Dr. James Benninger noted the high number of pediatric COVID cases that have occurred in schools that have already reopened without mask mandates in states such as Florida and Texas.

“If we trust the (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention), if we trust the doctors that do this day in and day out, they will tell you that the masking works,” he said. “The virus doesn’t care about your freedoms and your policies.”

Angela Heisman said that wearing masks has “severe mental health consequences” for students.

Advertise with us

“When you mask a child, you have stolen their voice and identity,” she said. “This is going to be a lost generation and the people masking children are going to be responsible for this.”

Jen Gianfresca said she believes that Mars Area will be virtual within a month if masks are not mandated.

“I’ve never seen so many people want to put the health of their kids at risk,” she said. “Politics should not be the driving force behind this decision.”

Dr. David Smolenski, a chiropractor, said that, because most bacteria and germs are in the mouth, the mask can do more harm than good.

“Having a mask on our child is literally useless, but it is harmful,” he said. “If air is getting through those masks, viruses are getting through those masks.”

Advertise with us

Board member Christine Valenta, who was attending the meeting virtually from Dallas, said that masks should be worn since a large portion of the student body is not eligible to be vaccinated and there is no way of knowing how many of the older students have gotten the vaccine.

Schools in Dallas have been open for two weeks, she said. “Right now, no more ICU beds are available for pediatric patients,” she said. “My fear is that we will find ourselves in a similar situation.

“The most conservative route is the safest route.”

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.