A Pennsylvania lawmaker wants to make sure all public school and college students have the option of in-person instruction five days a week once fall rolls around, if not sooner.

House Appropriations Committee Chairman Stan Saylor, R-York County, said it is his intention to make access to full face-to-face instruction a condition for school districts, community colleges, technical schools and state universities to receive state funding in the 2021-22 budget.

Groups that advocate for public schools and colleges view Saylor’s demand as unwelcome but not too worrisome, since they say they intend to bring students back to the classroom as the state and nation look to put the COVID-19 pandemic in the rearview later this year.

But others see it as an unhelpful and unproductive, putting partisanship ahead of the health and safety of kids. One lawmaker even suggests Saylor’s notion would be unconstitutional.

Advertise with us

In a statement, Saylor blamed “special interests and others” for fighting to keep schools closed to in-person instruction during the pandemic.

“We appropriate over $16.6 billion from the state’s General Fund to support PreK-12 and higher education,” Saylor said. “If school districts, technical schools, community colleges or universities do not open their doors to full-time, in-person instruction, working with my colleagues, I will push to ensure the school code prohibits them from accessing these dollars.”

Numerous studies have found remote learning to be contributing to learning loss, particularly among younger students, English language learners and those with special needs. Some child advocates and doctors say authorities aren’t getting as many reports of child abuse and neglect because many kids are not in school.

The statement from Saylor, who was unavailable for in interview, pointed to a report by McKinsey & Co. that suggests some students, particularly students of color, could be as much as a full year behind in their learning by the end of this school year as a result of remote learning.

The statement from Saylor, who was unavailable for in interview, pointed to a report by McKinsey & Co. that suggests some students, particularly students of color, could be as much as a full year behind in their learning by the end of this school year as a result of remote learning.

Advertise with us

Getting back to the classroom

For the students who find a virtual learning environment to be better for them, Saylor wants that to remain an option for them. But his spokesman Neal Lesher said, “For those students who want to get back in the classroom five days a week, whether it be K-12 or community college or university, we think they need to move toward that.”

Lesher said the Centers for Disease Control guidelines say schools can reopen with a mask requirement and three feet of social distancing. He said Saylor would like to see that happen even before next school year if possible.

Schools have received nearly $6 billion from three different federal funding laws to assist with their reopening efforts to get students back into classrooms and address their academic, social, emotional and mental health needs.

The most recent, The American Rescue Plan, provides $4.5 billion to school districts and charter schools. The relief package requires at least 20% of the money to be used to address learning loss and the needs of underrepresented students, including students from low-income families, students with disabilities, English learners, migrant students, students experiencing homelessness, and children in foster care.

Advertise with us

“This extra funding is critical to help schools meet the unique needs of educating students at this time while keeping school buildings safe when students return to the classroom,” Gov. Tom Wolf said.

The state has also launched a vaccination effort targeting teachers and school staff and Wolf said that initiative is ahead of schedule. The federal aid and the vaccination program provide “another sign of hope,” said Lyndsay Kensinger, a spokeswoman for the governor.

“With the combination of the vaccine special program, federal funding and the dedication of school communities, we expect schools to open normally and the representative’s unproductive threats are a distraction from that process,” Kensinger said.

Sen. Lindsey Williams, D-Allegheny County, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Education Committee, said she has no doubt students, teachers and parents want to get back to the classroom in a way that is safe and she expects that is likely by the fall.

But she added the option for how instruction is delivered needs to remain flexible.

Advertise with us

“There’s a reason why we have local control of our schools so that God forbid, there’s not another variant that’s not responsive to the vaccine and there’s an outbreak in a certain area,” Williams said. “The school needs to be able to respond to that and keep their kids safe without jeopardizing their state funding. It’s ridiculous to tie that together. You’re putting a partisan message over health and safety of kids.”

House Democratic Appropriations Committee Chairman Matt Bradford of Montgomery County agrees that districts need to retain that flexibility given the evolving circumstances regarding the virus and its variants.

“The General Assembly should be a constructive partner in this struggle, not an inflexible and punitive force,” Bradford said.

As of Monday afternoon, the state Department of Education reports 27% of school districts (212), charter schools, technical schools and intermediate units are operating full in-person learning models. Some 42% of those schools (333) are in scaffolded or blended learning models. The remaining 32% (248) remain using a fully remote instructional model.

Plans for the fall

Advertise with us

HACC, Central Pennsylvania’s community college, has been operating fully remote since last March and announced its intention to remain that way through the upcoming summer semesters. But according to a college spokesperson, HACC plans to offer classes in a variety of way sincluding on-campus offerings in the fall.

A spokesman for the 14 state universities said all of the institutions are hoping and planning to offer in-person instruction in the fall. Penn State, Pitt and Temple universities are also planning for face-to-face classes in the fall.

The same goes for public school districts.

Annette Stevenson, a spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said based on discussions with school leaders, they all are moving in that direction “even as there’s been such uncertainties around how exactly to accomplish it.”

Mark DiRocco, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators, said between the stimulus funds, vaccination program and latest federal guidelines, it should assist school districts with their desire to return to full-time in-person learning.

Advertise with us

But DiRocco indicated the state funding is essential for schools, even as Saylor has threatened to withhold the money unless in-person, five-day-a-week instruction is provided.

“State subsidy dollars will be needed for all public schools to open and we look forward to working with the General Assembly to provide the increased subsidy funding needed to help districts safely open their schools for the 2021-2022 school year,” he said.

Pennsylvania State Education Association spokesman Chris Lilienthal criticized Saylor’s proposal.

“It’s unfortunate that Rep. Saylor is resorting to threats rather than seeking out ways to work collaboratively with school leaders, educators, parents, and other stakeholders as we move toward creating a safer environment for in-person instruction. Policymakers should be focused on keeping students and their families safe, not putting politics over science,” Lilienthal said.

‘Making a point’

Advertise with us

Rep. Jesse Topper, R-Bedford County, has made no secret about his concern about the toll this pandemic has had on children’s education. So he is fully supportive of the added pressure that Saylor wants to place on school officials to make in-person, five-days-a-week learning available for those who need it this fall.

“I think he’s making the point. We always say the budget shows our priorities as a state government,” Topper said. “The role of the government is to make sure there are options available and the bottom line is the option of face-to-face instruction especially for our most vulnerable students has not been made available to them for an entire, in some cases, a year now and that’s simply unacceptable.”

Meanwhile, Rep. Mark Longietti, D-Mercer County, said as more school personnel are vaccinated, he sees more districts are returning to in-person instruction so Saylor’s perceived threat “may not be the burning issue it’s made out to be.”

Besides, Longietti said what Saylor is proposing to do in tying state dollars to a requirement that schools reopen for in-person learning may not square with the state constitution.

Longietti, the ranking Democrat on the House Education Committee, pointed to provision in the constitution requiring the General Assembly to provide for “the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of public education.”

Advertise with us

“I don’t think it is within our constitutional authority to deny school districts funding and just shut them off,” Longietti said.

For Saylor, the rub is seeing some districts not yet move toward in-person learning while some charter schools and private schools have managed to stay open since the pandemic began, aside from perhaps having to close for a week because of potential cases, said Lesher, his spokesman.

“We think every student should have that opportunity regardless of their zip code,” Lesher said. “But the CDC themselves, their recommendation is that schools should be open with three feet of social distancing and masks and sanitizing. We think those things can be done particularly with $6 billion that school districts have received from the federal government.”