Parents say their children need to be in school for the sake of their education and mental health.
Teachers say it’s too great a risk to bring back students before staff members can access the COVID-19 vaccine.
Now, the Pittsburgh Public Schools board must decide what to do.
Board members Monday evening heard dozens of testimonials from teachers, parents, students and other concerned citizens who displayed deep disagreements on how the district should handle instruction as the pandemic continues. This comes as the board is set to vote Wednesday on a measure that would move the district’s in-person reopening from February to April.
The vast majority of city students have been in a remote instruction model since mid-March when schools closed in an effort to slow the spread of the virus. Meanwhile, most other school districts in Allegheny County have had at least some in-person instruction for their students this school year.
Parents expressed frustration that their children are not being provided with the opportunity to return to class while students in nearby districts as well as private, parochial and charter schools have been back for most of the year.
Read More
“Does the board and administration actually believe that they care about my child’s health and well-being more than I do, more than the other families and caregivers that support and expect in-person education?” said Christine Zundel, the parent of a CAPA 6-12 student. “Does the board and administration believe that they care more than all the districts public, private, large and small in the county, state of Pennsylvania and the nation — more than those parents and families, more than those school boards, more than those administrators, more than those teachers?”
Robin Dunn, the parent of a kindergartner and a preschooler at Allegheny K-5, said remote instruction has placed a burden on his family because he and his wife have full-time jobs.
To be able to supervise their children, he said, they were faced with the decision that either one of them would have to quit their job or they would have to hire a nanny.
“We hired a nanny and were able to adjust our budget to afford it. But it’s not been easy,” Dr. Dunn said, adding that he feels “lucky” to have the means to bring in help when so many other families in the city do not.
Hannah Bedeck, a sophomore at CAPA 6-12, said as the district approaches the one-year mark of online learning, it has become increasingly difficult for students to maintain a positive mindset and healthy work ethic.
She expressed concern that her virtual education has not met the standard that it would have had she been in school.
“Though we are still attending class in some aspect, the curricula are nowhere near as rigorous as they would have been in person,” she said. “Without midterms and other benchmarks, we are not held to the same academic standards as we would have been otherwise.”

While parents and students want schools to reopen in February, board members are under heavy pressure from the teachers union to continue virtual learning into the spring.
Nina Esposito-Visgitis, president of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers, said the executive board of the union unanimously adopted a resolution urging the superintendent and the board to delay the start of in-person learning until school staff can receive vaccinations. She said district employees will not be able to get the vaccine until at least February.
“What this means to PPS employees is potential leaves of absence and possible staff shortages, a weakened ability to deliver educational programs and a proven risk of increased illness, hospitalization or death,” she said.
Many teachers and other staff members who provided testimony said that after all of this time, the district should not rush reopening now since the vaccine will soon be available.
“A vaccination is the only guarantee of a healthy return,” said Racheal Piccolino, a para-professional at Carrick High School. “Why would we risk that when we are this close?”
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.