Plans to recast California, Clarion and Edinboro universities as one entity with a shared budget, faculty and course inventory advanced Wednesday as the State System of Higher Education’s governing board endorsed what it calls “integration.”
The grouping is one of two that, together, would blend six of the State System’s 14 state-owned universities into two entities that officials say can better navigate enrollment losses and financial troubles compounded by the pandemic.
The other grouping endorsed is in Central Pennsylvania and involves pooling resources between Lock Haven, Mansfield and Bloomsburg universities.

It’s not fully clear how, and if, the State System can balance financial realities with its founding mission to ensure all Pennsylvanians equitable access to a high-quality low-cost education. Act 188, which created the system in 1982, enshrined that goal, though member schools in the years since have grown uneven in enrollment and financial health, in part due to population loss in parts of the state.
The 14 universities with almost 94,000 students have lost 22% of their enrollment over the past decade, with higher losses on some campuses.
Wednesday’s unanimous board of governors vote means system and campus administrators will bring an implementation plan to the board for review and a vote in April. If approved, it would trigger a 60-day public review process including at least two public hearings, with a vote to implement in July 2021.
Read More
The combined institutions would enroll their first students in August 2022.
Also Wednesday, Indiana University of Pennsylvania announced a restructuring of its colleges and programs, given a 33% decline in enrollment since 2010.
In recent months, State System leaders have shied away calling the campus integrations mergers. Even so, questions are being asked about what the unified institutions would look like.
Will their names change? How will student opportunities for in-person classes be divided among the campuses — separated in the case of California and Edinboro by 150 miles? What happens to extracurricular activities duplicated on the campuses including athletics? Would they be merged?
State System Chancellor Daniel Greenstein said those questions will be part of robust discussion as the implementation plans head to the board. “The hard work begins now,” he said.
He insisted that combining institutions does not reduce opportunities, and in fact, he predicted it will lead to expanded options as the campuses leverage their abilities to provide student support and academic programming while potentially reducing net cost to students. He said campus identity would be honored.
“It’s all about expanding opportunities for students,” he said in an interview Tuesday before the board met.
He reiterated that position as board members deliberated Wednesday.
“This is not just adding A, B and C ... but creating something new,” he said of the groupings. “This is an opportunity to think big and go big.”
Sharon Minnich, State System vice chancellor for administration and finance, presented data from a financial analysis indicating the groupings would have favorable impacts on enrollment and finances.
Preliminary system projections indicate enrollment growth of 4% to 5% for the two grouped institutions, and through greater efficiencies and leveraging combined size, potential for improved operating margins and reserves within three to five years, officials said.
Mr. Greenstein said the hope is that in addition to a traditional residential experience, California, Clarion and Edinboro will further develop online programs and that Bloomsburg, Lock Haven and Mansfield can pursue flexible non-degree certificate and credential programs to enhance Northern Pennsylvania's job market.
The 14 system campuses are the least expensive university option in Pennsylvania, but their price advantage over state-related universities including Penn State University and the University of Pittsburgh has slipped. Systemwide enrollment peaked at 119,513 but in the decade since has fallen by 22% to 93,708, with some campuses experiencing far larger losses.
In the west, the grouping connects three institutions of varying size and student outcomes: Cal U with 6,885 students, a 71% second-year retention rate and 55% six-year graduation rate; Clarion with 4,465 students, a 77% second-year retention rate and 53% six-year graduation rate; and Edinboro, with 4,319 students, a 74% second-year persistence rate and a 53% six-year graduation rate.
They also illustrate a wide wealth disparity across the 14 campuses.
The three universities combined have total unrestricted net assets of almost $60 million versus $173 million at West Chester University, largest of the 14 universities.
Campus presidents involved in both groups spoke in support of integration.
“We believe there is opportunity there for all three of our universities to thrive under this plan,” said Cal U President Geraldine Jones.
Other presidents — including those at Clarion, Edinboro and Mansfield — also said they saw promise in areas, including adult education and online learning.
Others expressed concern about potential inequities involving race and students with disabilities. Among them was Jamie Martin, president of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties.
She said the university groupings relate to a system goal of restoring student-faculty ratios to 21 to 1, as it was during the year of peak enrollment in 2010. She said classes that year were oversized and that faculty ranks already have been thinned in the years since.
Potential layoffs of 300 or more faculty will impact students and — for her members — mean loss of income and health insurance in a pandemic.
She said rising tuition does not capture the full story of why students are paying more at system universities. For years, she said, the State System went deep into debt building residence halls, student centers and other facilities financed by student fees — developments now underused as enrollment has plummeted.
“The predictable result is that housing costs skyrocketed, as did other types of fees. At most of our universities, housing costs and fees far outpace tuition costs,” she said. “This is an important part of the narrative.”
The State System does not have the authority to close a university, but — under recently enacted Act 50 — it can expand, consolidate and integrate campuses. The law exempts IUP and West Chester from those potential changes because their enrollment last year topped 10,000 students.
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.
Updated at 10:29 a.m. on 10/15/2020






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.