College leaders face plenty of hard decisions, but few are as agonizing as what bore down Tuesday on West Chester University’s president Christopher Fiorentino and his aides as they weighed growing risks from COVID-19.
Canceling face-to-face classes halfway through spring semester and moving them online, not to mention shuttering dorms and curtailing some activities, would have enormous consequences and costs for everyone on the 17,700-student campus — where no one so far has the novel coronavirus.
But doing anything less carried big risks, too, for leaders trying to keep students and employees safe on the suburban Philadelphia campus as confirmed cases of the virus continued to grow in Eastern Pennsylvania and nationally.
“We spent hours and hours and days going through the scenarios. ‘What’s the best way to do this?’” he said. “I kept coming back to the fact that most strategies would require us to hope things break a certain way. This was the only strategy where we felt we had sufficient control.”
But something additional led West Chester Tuesday become the first of Pennsylvania’s 14 state-owned universities to suspend in-person classes for the remainder of the semester. Namely, it was 10,000 responses to a registrar’s survey of student travel plans this week. It reinforced that these next five days were key.
“Over 3,000 students said they would be traveling, and well over 1,000 said it would be by air, bus, train or cruise ship. Over 400 said they would be traveling abroad,” Mr. Fiorentino said. “I thought, ‘What are the chances of all these people going and not one is going to bring the virus back.’’
Read More
All day Tuesday, other campuses wrestled with similar choices, and some made announcements, including a decision by Carnegie Mellon University-Silicon Valley to suspend face-to-face instruction on its campus in Mountain View, Calif., and conduct classes remotely until further notice starting March 16. That’s when students return from spring break.
A statement on the university’s website early Tuesday cited “increasing cases of the coronavirus (COVID-19) in the County of Santa Clara, California.” The campus is within that county and has about 45 faculty and staff and about 300 engineering graduate students in various programs.
Earlier, CMU shuttered its campus in Qatar, postponed classes there for two days and planned to resume instruction online indefinitely on Thursday. Neither Carnegie Mellon’s New York City site or the main Pittsburgh campus had announced any similar moves by late Tuesday.
However, CMU and other Pittsburgh-area campuses have been drawing up contingencies that include giving faculty assistance in devising ways to move face-to-face courses online should any of the schools decide to pause in-person instruction.
David Pidgeon, a State System of Higher Education spokesman, said the other 13 state-owned universities "are making decisions based on what is best for their campuses" and "if they decide to make additional precautionary measures, they’ll be the ones to announce."
In recent days, a number of major universities, including those on the West Coast, have paused in-person instruction. Among the schools are the University of Washington, Stanford, the University of California at Berkeley and the University of California at San Diego.
On the East Coast, Harvard University said it, too, will switch to remote teaching. Earlier, Columbia and Princeton universities announced similar moves.
Ohio State University says it also is suspending in-person classes effective immediately and with deliver them virtually at least through March 30, saying it wants to slow spread of the virus by minimizing close-up interaction.
There are more than 118,000 cases of the virus globally and nearly 4,300 deaths.
At West Chester, largest of the state-owned campuses, the move was announced Tuesday afternoon in a message to students and employees. Officials said courses already online will resume once students return from break Monday, while other courses now delivered in person will be paused until March 30, then delivered remotely.
About 90% of West Chester’s courses are delivered in-person, but with two weeks to prepare, Mr. Fiorentino expressed confidence that West Chester has the capacity and resources to make the switch. Faculty and staff will use various methods including the course management system D2L, he said.
“What we’re looking at is a whole array of video-conferencing,” he explained. “We can still conduct classes over Skype and Zoom, video conference systems where a faculty member can deliver a lecture in real time and the students can be at home,” he said.
Commencement “is still a couple months out” so a decision on that gathering has not been made. Students on spring sports teams play outdoors, travel in coach buses and thus are being allowed for now to compete, though with dorms closed, there could be complications for the athletes.
Administrators do not yet have an anticipated financial cost, but Mr. Fiorentino said said it will no doubt be substantial, given everything from making students whole for financial losses to work associated with the instructional switch.
He said the emotional costs are as troubling. Seniors, for instance, were looking forward to their last weeks on campus with friends as they reach a milestone in their lives.
“There are a lot of very disappointed people,” he said. “Now, all of a sudden, it’s not going to be what that thought it was going to be.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner








Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.