People who spoke at a Pittsburgh Public Schools budget hearing Monday seemed more concerned about the district’s proposed funding for counseling and mental health services than the proposed 2.3% tax increase.

About 15 people addressed district officials, including many who said they represented advocacy groups and urged reallocation of funding away from security and toward social services.

The 2020 budget would fund 92 employees for security, about 45 counselors and about 40 social workers. Advocates recommended that the district increase its in-school mental health providers by lowering the number of security personnel.

“If we actually had that many service providers, instead of security guards and police officers, I think our students would be better served,” said Angel Gober, the Western Pennsylvania director of the social justice group OnePA, and a resident of the North Side.

Advertise with us

She said providing more mental health resources could reduce the necessity of school security by getting students the help they need, leading to a decrease in violence.

Board member Sylvia Wilson said after the hearing that she doesn’t want to see the safety of students “put on question” and that she believes school security does a good job.

One of the strengths of the district, Ms. Wilson said, is that many of the schools are partnered with mental health agencies that can provide services to students.

“It doesn’t matter if you’re in the best community or the worst community … kids have issues no matter where they are, and it seems like we are identifying them more and more,” she said. “So the partnerships that we have help to address a lot of those needs.”

The $665.6 million budget proposal, which calls for a 2.3% property tax increase, faces a school board vote Dec. 18. Many of those who spoke at the meeting Monday said they supported the tax increase.

Advertise with us

But city officials, including Mayor Bill Peduto, have been at odds with the district recently on a number of issues, including spending, travel and the proposed tax hike. As school officials listened to public comment on the budget Monday afternoon, Mr. Peduto, speaking at a city budget hearing across town, recommended revisiting a model that once improved public trust in the district.

He endorsed a suggestion by Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith to bring back a community education committee that, he said, helped smooth friction between the district, the teachers union and foundations that were donating to the schools about five years ago.

Mr. Peduto said his staff would reach out to the councilwoman in coming days to get the process started. He did not say whether the creation of the committee would require legislation or school district buy-in, nor who would be on the committee.

“We have to work together,” said the mayor, even as he continued to raise questions about school district spending.

“There is a willingness to want to work together, and there is an interest in getting more of a community involvement to build trust,” the mayor said. “The statements that I made, and that I made public, are the questions that I believe that the board members should have been asking.”

Advertise with us

He said he recently spoke with three members of the school board — he did not name them — and said he “didn’t get much disagreement” on the need for sharper questioning of district spending.

“There should be more of an inquiry into the no-bid contracts that have been awarded” by the district, the mayor said. “From what I’ve been told from those that work for the district, these are mounting into the tens of millions of dollars.”

He added that “in the six years that I’ve been mayor, the [district] budget has already increased $137 million, even though enrollment’s down and the number of employees is up.”

“And I know that they say that a big part of that is charter schools,” he said. “That should be information that’s made available to the public. What percent of it is charter schools? What percent of it is going to contractors, vendors and through no-bid contracts, and why? Before raising taxes, those questions should be answered. And I would hope the school board would do that.”

He reiterated that he wouldn’t forego the 0.25 percentage point of income tax revenue that the district ceded to the city some 15 years ago, despite suggestions from some in the district that the schools need it more than the city. “We’re balancing our budget based on that,” he said.

Advertise with us

He offered, though, to “knock on doors for our kids and be able to be the lobbyist that they need in Harrisburg and the person that can bring corporations and foundations and others to the assistance of the schools.”

A school district spokeswoman could not be reached later Monday to comment on the mayor’s remarks.