ELYRIA, Ohio — In a small courtroom in Lorain County, attorneys in a libel case that has gotten national attention argued over punitive damages for the bakery that won its libel case against Oberlin College.
The court reconvened Wednesday after the Ohio jury ordered Oberlin to pay $11 million to Gibson’s Food Mart and Bakery, which said it was libeled and wrongfully accused of racially profiling students.
The case stems from the November 2016 arrests of three black Oberlin students at the family-owned bakery near the college's campus in Oberlin, Ohio.
After that, Oberlin staff members tried to discredit the family-owned bakery, the lawsuit says.
Punitive damages can be set to any amount under $22 million.
“There can be no crime without appropriate responsibility and punishment. In our country, no one can expect or demand special treatment. … The fabric of our country would fall apart if, in fact, you are a victim who tries to stop or protect against crime, [and] you are retaliated against,” said Lee Plakas, lead attorney for the Gibson family.
Read More
Punitive damages are meant as both a punishment for the college and a deterrent for similar future conduct — not only for Oberlin, but for “any other institution from committing similar acts,” Mr. Plakas said. He said that the deterrence aspect of the case is the most important aspect for himself and the nation.
He told the jury that the punitive damages determined will “protect everyone else in our country, in our state, in our community – protects them to ensure that they don’t have to go through what the Gibsons went through.”
“If indeed there was interest, if indeed you come across stories in the New York Times, or the Washington Post, or FOX News on TV or CNN or Wall Street Journal … why do you think they would have been and are so interested?” Mr. Plakas asked the jury.
Mr. Plakas submitted to the jury that interest in the case has arisen because of a “national tipping point” caused by the way in which words have become weapons, and the importance of educating youth properly.
Rachelle Zidar, an attorney for Oberlin College, reminded the jury of the power they have and the magnitude of their verdict nationwide. “Ladies and gentlemen, you have spoken. You have sent a profound message. We have heard you. Believe me when I say, colleges across the country have heard you.”
Ms. Zidar said the school knew something needed to change even before the jury issued their verdict. She said the school is more closely monitoring activities of student organizations, including how the college responds to student protests. She said the school is increasing oversight over its student senate and the resolutions it passes, improving internal communications, and making it clear “from day one” that the students will be held accountable for their actions and have a duty of good citizenship.
The college introduced a new orientation program named “Community 101: An Obie’s Guide to Being a Good Neighbor” in August, 2018, for the new Oberlin first-year class. The program, which featured speakers including the chief prosecutor, city manager, and police chief, is designed to help new students “think through their responsibilities as residents of the city of Oberlin,” according to an email sent out by the college’s president.
“What are some things that aren’t malice? Well obviously, negligence is not malicious. It’s wrong; you can hold somebody liable for it. But it’s not malicious,” Ms. Zidar said. “It’s not bad judgment. It’s not aloofness. It’s not misguided ideology. It’s not a failure to investigation. It’s not foul language. It’s not being inconsiderate, being rash, being impulsive.”
The Gibson’s legal team capitalized on the argument that was disallowed in the first compensatory, phase of the trial: the wealth and resources of Oberlin College.
“Everything is relative,” Mr. Plakas told the jury, saying that paying over $100 is a “mosquito bite” for a millionaire.
Mr. Plakas utilized the refrain comparing the trial to a “David and Goliath battle,” characterizing Oberlin as a “billion-dollar institution that can afford, in this case, 11 attorneys.”
Both sides cross-examined Rebecca Vazquez-Skillings, Oberlin vice president of finance and administration, attempting to give the jury a picture of the economic state of the university.
Representing the Gibson family, attorney Owen Rarric said that the college has over $1.4 billion in total assets. He pointed out that the college’s endowment is $887 million. He stated that annual student charges for tuition and room and board are roughly $70,000.
Oberlin attorney Matthew Nakon responded that the college has been operating in an unsustainable deficit situation year after year — a situation caused largely by substantial declines in enrollment numbers. Mr. Nakon said that outside of a small portion of the endowment, the college has little to no discretion over how the endowment is spent.
Instead, individual donors hold this discretion. He also added that roughly 90% of Oberlin students are on scholarships.
Ms. Vasquez-Skillings emphasized that enrollment numbers have declined, and that the college has been operating at an unsustainable deficit. “Ultimately what the punitive damages portion intends is to teach an institution not to pour gasoline on fires. What will it take to get them to change their attitude? What will it take to get others, similarly situated, to change their attitude?”
The Gibson family attorneys also brought forward Meredith Raimondo, Oberlin vice president and dean of students, as a witness, who confirmed her writing of textual evidence -— including text messages and emails -— from the case. Oberlin lawyers brought current Oberlin president Carmen Twillie Ambar to testify about changes the college has been making.
On Thursday morning, attorneys from both sides will make their closing statements and the jury is expected to make a decision by the end of the day.
Contact Sammy Westfall at swestfall@theblade.com, 419-724-6194, or on Twitter @sammy_westfall.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.