A Slippery Rock University vice president claims in a federal lawsuit that discrimination against his Iranian origin, his Muslim faith and his race blocked him from SRU’s presidency in fall 2017 and later at Clarion University.

In a complaint filed Thursday in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, Amir Mohammadi alleges that discriminatory acts and retaliation twice thwarted his promotion, despite a three-decade-plus career in academia and successful leadership at Slippery Rock.

Named as defendants are the university, the State State System of Higher Education and Robert S. Taylor, a Slippery Rock trustee and member of SRU’s presidential search committee.

Mr. Mohammadi, 59, asserts in the lawsuit that Mr. Taylor tried to thwart his candidacy through bullying during committee sessions, by falsely claiming a conflict of interest and breaking search confidentiality rules by leaking that allegation to news outlets including the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

“By all accounts, Dr. Mohammadi has been a successful top manager at Slippery Rock in terms of finance, construction, development, procurement and sustainability,’’ the suit states. “Dr. Mohammadi had earned consistent praise for his performance in his position at SRU.”

Mr. Mohammadi is a naturalized U.S. citizen who immigrated to this country in the 1980s while in college. He is Slippery Rock’s vice president for finance and administration and has taken on additional duties when needed including advancement.

He “probably had the best record and credentials” for the presidency, the lawsuit says. But, “When Dr. Mohammadi surfaced as a leading candidate the search became irregular and Mr. Taylor, who served as a member of the search committee, tried to thwart him from being recommended to be President.”

He claims he was treated differently than internal candidates in previous SRU presidential searches who were white, of U.S. origin and non-Muslim.  “...they were not subjected to similar accusations of conflict of interest, nor were their candidacies blocked,’’ the lawsuit states.

Robb King, a Slippery Rock spokesman, and Kenn Marshall, a State System spokesman, both declined to comment on the pending litigation. Mr. Taylor could not be reached.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit alleges that Mr. Mohammadi’s constitutional rights were violated. It seeks a jury trial and all damages available under Pennsylvania law.

The search for a successor to Cheryl Norton at Slippery Rock progressed during 2017, but took an unusual and controversial turn by the fall.

In October, without explaining why, Slippery Rock announced that trustees had deadlocked 5-5 over forwarding two finalists to the State System and decided against forwarding either name — Bruce Murphy, president of Nicholls State University in Thibodaux, La., and Mr. Mohammadi.

They and a third contender, Marsha Krotseng, president of Bluefield State College in Bluefield, W.Va., surfaced in a process that drew dozens of applicants.

The Post-Gazette and Butler Eagle reported on the allegation from Mr. Taylor, an attorney and Slippery Rock alumnus who is chairman and chief executive officer of the Cameron Companies LLC. In a letter to the system and university, he called for an investigation of what he claimed was “a significant breach of integrity” that had occurred within the search process.

Advertise with us

His letter said two among the 16 search committee members were SRU employees who report directly to Mr. Mohammadi, and as such, there was a conflict of interest.

System officials said the relationship did not pose a conflict, and others on the committee disputed Mr. Taylor’s claim that the employee-supervisor relationship had not been disclosed.

In his suit, Mr. Mohammadi said Mr. Taylor, as a search committee member and trustee, “vaguely warned other members not to advance Dr. Mohammadi’s name but declined to explain why.

“Mr. Taylor made derogatory statements regarding Dr. Mohammadi in the past; for instance, on one occasion he mocked Dr. Mohammadi for sounding like a ‘Mid-Western American’ when Dr. Mohammadi quoted Henry Ford and Will Rogers.”

His lawsuit accused Mr.Taylor of leaking to the newspaper his accusation about a conflict of interest.The suit also cited a letter to the State System chancellor’s office that was published in the student newspaper, The Rocket. It was penned by a majority of the committee complaining about Mr. Taylor’s actions and asked that he be removed, but the lawsuit says the State System declined to do so.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit also asserted that then search committee chair Jeffrey Smith reported that there had been racial animus amid the search as evidenced by a comment purportedly by a Slippery Rock trustee that “no Persian would ever be selected as President of the University.”

Reached Thursday evening, Mr. Smith said he remembers it being an online comment of some kind not necessarily attached to a trustee. “It could have come from who knows where,” he said.

Seven months after the  failed search at Slippery Rock, Mr. Mohammadi emerged as a leading candidate in the presidential search at Clarion, another State System school.

In his lawsuit, Mr. Mohammadi says as the search committee prepared to decide who among four candidates including Mr. Mohammadi should advance, the conflict-of-interest allegation resurfaced in a Post-Gazette story reporting a claim of discrimination made by Mr. Mohammadi and a system investigation of it.

The article was a result of Mr. Taylor’s actions, the lawsuit claims, and caused his candidacy to be “rejected” due to adverse publicity, the lawsuit alleges.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazettet.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.