“Restorative practices” have been touted among experts and advocates as a key tool to reduce school suspensions and expulsions — and particularly racial disparities among them.

It’s a strategy to improve school culture and build better, more communicative relationships between students and teachers rather than pushing students out of the classroom for bad behavior.

And it seems to be showing positive results in Pittsburgh Public Schools, at least according to the preliminary results of a years-long, federally funded study of restorative practices at 22 city schools.

The RAND Corporation released preliminary results of a two-year study on restorative practices in Pittsburgh schools, research that began shortly after the district was awarded a $3 million grant from the U.S. Department of Justice in 2014. Teachers at 22 schools were trained by the International Institute for Restorative Practices, and those schools were paired with and compared to 22 “control” schools with certain similarities, like suspension rates. Researchers also surveyed the teachers, to gauge their use and understanding of the new program.

Advertise with us

Overall, the study found, suspensions at schools that participated decreased more than they did at other district schools during the 2015-16 and 2016-17 school years.

“It was really, really exciting and really, really validating,” said Christine Cray, PPS’ director of student services reforms.

RAND researchers Catherine Augustine and John Engberg presented the preliminary findings to the school board last week, and said the study is undergoing one more peer review before the final report is released in December.

Suspensions in PPS overall decreased during the 2015-16 and 2016-17 school years, from 16 percent of students suspended to 13 percent, Mr. Engberg said. But in the schools that used restorative practices during that period, the suspension rates dropped twice as much as in the control group. Prior to implementation, black students were suspended four times as often as white students, and that rate dropped slightly to 3.5 times as often as white students, the study found. The suspension rates of economically-disadvantaged students also dropped from three times to twice as often as non-economically disadvantaged students.

The “best results” were in kindergarten through fifth grade, the researchers said. The number of days students were suspended and the number of repeat suspensions dropped, the report said. The use of restorative practices had little effect on standardized test scores, but those schools also reported fewer student absences.

Advertise with us

At the middle school level, suspensions went up slightly, the report found. Test scores were slightly higher at the “control” schools that weren’t using the restorative practices. The participating schools did, however, report fewer referrals to the the district’s alternative program.

Because of the randomized pairings of the schools with control schools, the researchers were not able to provide an apples-to-apples comparison of the district’s large high schools.

Mr. Engberg, a senior economist with RAND, said the suspension increase and lower test scores at the middle-school level could be temporary as those students take a bit more time to adjust. Introducing new programs into a classroom — and asking teachers to devote time to something else — can sometimes have that effect.

“Because the middle school students were new to this it actually took some time in the classroom to talk about restorative practices, develop those norms and that new culture of community,” he said. “We are encouraged by the fact that in the middle and high schools, the use of restorative practices seemed to increase from the first year to the second year, and that enthusiasm from the staff for the program seemed to stay high.”

Ms. Cray called the middle school results “puzzling,” and said the district has a number of hypotheses as to why the results in middle schools weren’t as good as in the elementary schools, ranging from the age of the students to length of the study period to the fact that elementary school students spend most of their day with a single teacher.

Advertise with us

District leaders still found the results of the study promising, in general, she said. The use of restorative practices has already been expanded district-wide as part of its new strategic plan. Other efforts to improve disparities in discipline —  including a ban on suspensions for students in kindergarten through second grade — are being phased in to address an issue the district has been criticized for for years.

“We kind of knew that regardless of what the RAND data said that this was work people felt really passionate about, really connected to,” Ms. Cray said. “I think it gives us the information (we need) to do it better, do what we've been doing in a more focused way.”

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or on Twitter @Ebehrman.