West Mifflin Area School District’s assistant superintendent testified at a board hearing that he recently received an inquiry from the state Department of Education stating it was seeking information about a second DUI arrest for superintendent Daniel Castagna.

The school board on Wednesday conducted its fourth Act 1080 public hearing to consider the removal of Mr. Castagna, who faces a number of accusations -- including a 2017 DUI charge in Beaver County, neglect of duties, incompetency and immorality under the Public School Code.

Assistant superintendent Mark Hoover said he forwarded the email to the district’s solicitor “because I was confused what they were asking about.” Mr. Hoover said the PDE email stated that the inquiry was prompted “by something they read in the newspaper” regarding Mr. Castagna.

“They were seeking information regarding a second DUI,” Mr. Hoover said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hoover said the email from PDE stated Dr. Castagna had two DUI arrests, but he reported the 2017 DUI as a first offense. Mr. Hoover said he was not aware of a second DUI arrest.

Mr. Castagna’s attorney, Colleen Ramage Johnston said after the hearing the timing of the PDE inquiry was “suspicious.”

A former board member also testified at the hearing.

Ronald Rubinsak, who was on the board from 2011 to 2015 testified he voted against renewing Mr. Castagna’s contract in September 2015, but never got the chance to tell him the reason.

Mr. Rubinsak testified he voted not to renew Mr. Castagna’s contract “primarily for the salary,” stating the five-year contract with a 3.5 percent raise was too much. He added he thought administrators should be subject to an annual performance evaluation.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rubinsak testified he did not state his reason for voting against the renewal at the September 2015 meeting, but called Mr. Castagna and set up a meeting with him the next day to let him know his reasons.

“I never got the chance to tell him,” he said, as Mr. Castagna “proceeded to berate me,” at a meeting between the two in the district’s administrative offices.

“He was yelling at me saying I was no good, my family was no good and that I was a bad father,” Mr. Rubinsak said.

Mr. Rubinsak testified he did not get to say anything during the meeting, which was held in Mr. Hoover’s office, with Mr. Hoover present.

“The only thing I said in that meeting was, ‘Dan, calm down,’” Mr. Rubinsak said.

Advertise with us

During her cross examination, Ms. Johnston asked Mr. Rubinsak if it was fair to say he had no performance concerns about Mr. Castagna. Mr. Rubinsak said although he did have some questions about him at times, Mr. Castagna “was a good superintendent.”

Ms. Johnston asked if he was aware that Mr. Castagna has had two performance reviews since he has been employed. Mr. Rubinsak said he was not aware.

In previous testimony, witnesses have accused Mr. Castagna of paying members of what looked to be the Sin City Desciples Motorcycle Club $200 each to come to a school board meeting to provide “intimidation and security.”

He’s also been accused of improperly conducting surveillance including secretly watching a school board member who had requested public records from the district before an election and ordering a district employee to improperly tape a school custodian who was receiving workers’ compensation to prove he was physically healthy; improperly ordering employees to perform work unrelated to school business on his behalf; and pushing for the hiring of a convicted murderer as a security guard in the district.

The board voted earlier this year to put Mr. Castagna on paid administrative leave after the 2017 DUI Charge came to light. In July, the board voted 6-3 to place him on unpaid leave with Janice Gladden, Judy Andzelik and Judith Ahern voting against the suspension.

Advertise with us

Mr. Castagna filed a federal lawsuit against the district and the six board members who voted to suspend him saying he had been wrongfully targeted because he reported wrongdoings by several district employees. A hearing on the suit is scheduled for next month.

A hearing that had been scheduled for Sept. 17 was cancelled. The next hearing dates will be Sept. 18, Oct. 9, Oct. 17 and Oct. 22 at West Mifflin Area Middle School.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.