The saga of the Midland Borough School District and its struggles to find a place for its high school students is highlighted in a new report about how some states "strand" students in impoverished schools.

EdBuild, a New Jersey-based think tank that researches school funding and equity issues across the country, released a report Tuesday that explores state policies regarding district mergers and consolidations. Pennsylvania is one of 39 states that allows districts to consolidate if both school boards agree, and does not offer any incentives or have a policy that allows the state mandate that districts do so.

"As a result, the more fortunate district holds the power to throw a lifeline or to withhold one," the report states. "And without the prospect of any real benefit, the well-off districts will almost certainly choose to maintain the status quo, leaving their neighbors stranded."

Researchers pointed to the Midland district in Beaver County as an example of how a failed merger can play out in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

In 1983, the district had sent merger requests to all the other school districts in Beaver County without any positive response, according to the EdBuild report. The district closed its high school in 1985, and for a time paid tuition for its older students to attend high school in the Beaver Area School District. That agreement ultimately fell through, and with no other options, the Midland district began paying tuition for its students to attend school in Ohio. In 2015, the East Liverpool School District in Ohio terminated the agreement, and Midland students are now spread between charter schools and Beaver Area schools, the result of a smaller new agreement.

The researchers found that 18 Pennsylvania school districts have sought consolidation since 2000. The merger of the Center Area and Monaca districts in 2009 has been the only success, the report states. The report looked at complete mergers, and did not include agreements like those that exist in Wilkinsburg or Duquesne City, where those districts pay tuition to send their students to schools in other districts.

"Ultimately, I think that in this point in the history of consolidation policy, what you're looking at is not that many attempts because there isn't a point," said Zahava Stadler, EdBuild's director of policy. Without any incentives or state mandates, districts that consider consolidating with another district tend to believe they'll never be able to, she said.

"That's why ultimately this needs to be a state policy solution," she said.

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter.