School districts often boast about their latest digital initiatives. Sleek devices and flashy technology in classrooms abound, depending on the school.
But Luddites, nostalgists and tech skeptics, fear not. While schools have expanded their digital footprints in recent years, they haven’t thrown out paper entirely.
“I don’t see print going away,” said Allison Mackley, president-elect of the Pennsylvania School Librarians Association. “There’s still a purpose for print resources.”
Although many of the state’s school libraries have diversified their offerings to include online resources and audio-books, their shelves typically also remain stocked with rows of books — the kind you can pick up and open — a characteristic familiar to generations of students past, she said.
“Students still want to be able to hold books in their hands and use sticky notes and enjoy that feel,” said Ms. Mackley, of Derry Township School District’s Hershey High School, near Harrisburg. “But I would say there’s also a shift in the behavior of students as researchers, and we have to adapt to their needs.”
The tech-versus-paper debate ultimately extends beyond a zero-sum game, a point that often gets lost in conversations about the role of education technology, said Daniel Oppenheimer, a psychology professor at Carnegie Mellon University’s Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences.
A 2014 study co-authored by Mr. Oppenheimer found that students who took longhand notes outperformed those who took notes on a computer. But what if the point of the task were to accurately record information? The computer would like prove advantageous. It ultimately comes down to the goal of the task, he said.
“Origami wouldn't work well with a computer,” Mr. Oppenheimer said in an email. “You can't search a document as quickly with paper than with an electronic file.”
But that hasn't slowed the shift from paper for some districts. Two local schools -- Mt. Lebanon High School and Wexford Elementary in the Pine-Richland School District -- recently received the U.S. Department of Education's 2018 Green Ribbon School Award. The recognition goes to schools that reduce their environmental impact and costs, and provide strong sustainability education.
North Hills School District has converted many traditionally print-oriented documents to digital. It posts many of its forms online and encourages families to print them out themselves, spokeswoman Amanda Hartle said. Tests and homework assignments throughout the district are widely administered on digital platforms, she said.
Baldwin-Whitehall School District has begun using Google platforms throughout the district. Principals conduct paperless surveys and training sessions among teachers and staff. Students are choosing paper less frequently, too, said Janeen Peretin, the district's director of information and instructional technology.
The Baldwin High School library's printer has seen an 83 percent drop in usage in recent years, Ms. Peretin said.
Penn Hills School District has also made much of its paperwork — including report cards and forms — available online, and accommodates families who may not have computer access, said spokeswoman Teresita Kolenchak. The district has cut down on mailers and no longer prints its yearly calendar, she said.
But Penn Hills students who show up late to class can still expect to receive a trusty old-fashioned tardy slip.
The district bought thousands of paper tardy slips before the start of the school year, according to the district’s check records.
Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.