When Mandy Steele O’Hara showed up at Fairview Elementary School to volunteer at a Valentine’s Day party in her first-grader’s classroom, she had her sleeping infant in tow.
Ms. Steele O’Hara, of Fox Chapel, said the infant needed to be with her because the baby was exclusively breastfed. Leaders at Fairview, in the Fox Chapel Area School District, told her that she couldn’t volunteer with the infant.
Ms. Steele O’Hara said she was capable of leading a Valentine’s Day craft with her baby at her side, and since then, she has fought unsuccessfully to get the school to change its policy.
Schools in the region take different approaches to having parents bring younger siblings when they volunteer in schools. Some encourage the practice as a way to promote inclusivity and community. Others discourage it, saying they don’t want volunteers to be distracted from working with students.
At Fairview, parents or guardians cannot bring younger siblings when they volunteer at a classroom party or function, said Bonnie Berzonski, a spokeswoman for the Fox Chapel Area School District.
“This issue is not about breastfeeding,” she said.
The purpose of the rule is so that volunteers can “give their undivided attention to the children attending the event, without having to attend to the needs of a younger child,” Ms. Berzonski said.
The North Hills School District agrees.
Volunteers are not supposed to bring younger children, said Amanda Hartle, a spokeswoman for North Hills.
“It is absolutely the expectation that when you volunteer, you volunteer, and you don’t bring any younger siblings along,” Ms. Hartle said.
Pittsburgh Public Schools takes a different approach, said Moira Kaleida, a parent and member of the district’s board of directors.
The district wants to include families in the educational process, and it is difficult to do that if a mom cannot bring her baby, said Ms. Kaleida of Beechview, who chairs the board’s policy committee.
“We know that parent involvement is critical when it comes to the success of our children,” she said. “If we do any sort of policy that makes that harder or makes it impossible, then we’re doing a disservice to our kids.”
She said she often brought her infant to Pittsburgh Montessori when she volunteered in the classroom or did clerical work there.
“I’ve never had an experience at Pittsburgh Public where my kid wasn’t encouraged to come along,” she said.
The Environmental Charter School has an “unspoken policy” that volunteers can bring babies and young children, said Kelly Abbott, a parent and fifth-grade teacher at the school, which has campuses in the city’s Point Breeze and Regent Square neighborhoods. Volunteering parents bring infants “on probably a daily basis,” she said.
“We think it’s really important to build community for parents to be in the building, and volunteer with their child,” Ms. Abbott said. “It also normalizes that moms are taking care of infants, and that they can do many things.”
Ms. Steele O’Hara wants Fairview to take a similar approach. Since Valentine’s Day, she has met with the school’s principal and a leadership team there and has spoken with the district’s solicitor in hopes of carving out an exception for breastfed infants.
She also has spoken with the Western Pennsylvania office of the Women’s Law Project and the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania.
Susan Frietsche, a staff attorney at the Women’s Law Project, said that under Pennsylvania law, a woman may breastfeed anywhere that she and the infant are otherwise permitted to be. “It almost puts the rabbit in the hat,” she said. “Are they legally permitted to be there, or are they not legally permitted to be there?”
Ms. Frietsche stressed that schools should “look very critically” at policies that have the effect of excluding mothers from volunteer opportunities.
“What we don’t want to see ever is women excluded from public life because of their reproductive capacity,” she said.
Ms. Steele O’Hara said she believes Fairview’s policy is sexist.
“It’s just an old-fashioned thing to think that babies are a distraction and you need to be at home with the baby,” she said.
Jamie Schuman, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.