A motion filed before a state panel seeking to halt a union vote by some 3,800 graduate assistants at Penn State University has been denied, meaning the election will occur next month as planned, officials confirmed Thursday.

The Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board decision cited a lack of standing by Penn State doctoral student Michael Cronin to intervene in the case. He is represented by the Fairness Center, a legal advocacy group that has taken up cases against public employee unions.

The one-page decision signed by board representative Peter Lassi said that in employee representation election proceedings, another employee representative can intervene with the requisite interest demonstrated.

"Here intervention is sought by an individual, and not by an employee representative, and no showing of interest has been provided,'' stated the document dated Wednesday. "Accordingly, Mr. Cronin lacks standing to intervene in this matter...Therefore, his motion is denied."

Advertise with us

In response, the Coalition of Graduate Employees at Penn State, which has indicated interest in affiliating with the Pennsylvania State Education Association, a teachers union, issued a statement Thursday. It said the election “will proceed as planned, with voting at University Park on April 10-13, 2018; Hershey on April 16, 2018; and Harrisburg on April 17, 2018."

Order Denying Motion to Intervene (PDF)

Order Denying Motion to Intervene (Text)

It called the decision a win for union workers.

“We’re pleased that the democratic process won out in the end,” said Jerome Clarke, co-President of the coalition. “The attempt to halt an election that the majority of graduate assistants here want was nothing more than the Fairness Center exhibiting its union-busting mission, and we’re glad the PLRB saw that as well.”

Advertise with us

Later Thursday, the center issued a statement quoting Mr. Cronin as saying he planned to explore his options and hoped all would both participate in the vote and fully understand its implications.

"I am happy to be a leader on this issue and to have taken a public stance against forced unionization," he said. "All voices on both sides of this issue are important, not just the loudest."

The case is being watched closely by graduate students and others at the University of Pittsburgh, another state-related university, where a drive is underway to form a union affiliated with the United Steelworkers.

It would represent about 2,000 graduate teaching and research assistants at Pitt. Graduate assistants at Temple University, a third-related university, already have union representation.

In February, the labor board ruled that assistants at several Penn State locations including the main University Park campus were workers, and as such, had a legal right to organize. Penn State maintained the individuals were not employees and challenged the drive.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Cronin, a doctoral student and graduate assistant who studies energy and mineral engineering, has said he does not see himself as a public employee. He asserts the duties he performs 20 hours a week in return for a stipend, benefits and tuition waivers are primarily educational, preparing him for a career.

"I accepted my appointment to further my education," he wrote in a affidavit attached to the motion, dated Friday. "Had I merely sought to earn money as an employee during my time as a doctoral student, I could have done something other than being a graduate assistant."

"I do not consent to the Coalition of Graduate Employees representation or to association with the Coalition of Graduate Employees," he wrote.

The center said in a statement announcing the student’s challenge Monday that the board ignored state Supreme Court precedent. Union supporters counter that the 1977 decision referenced did not apply and characterized the center’s representation of Mr. Cronin as an attack on unions.

The coalition petitioned the board for an election after a successful drive to secure enough signatures from potential members of the bargaining union who support the campaign.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG