Some community members have criticized the appointment of Brendan Hyland as Plum Schools superintendent, saying a 2014 lawsuit indicates he failed to respond adequately to a student’s complaints of bullying and sexual harassment while he was a North Allegheny principal.
Mr. Hyland was named Plum Borough School District superintendent Tuesday during a contentious meeting.
Some who spoke at the meeting mentioned the lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh, which included claims that the North Allegheny School District violated Title IX, the federal law that bars sex discrimination in public schools, and the Equal Protection clause of the Constitution.
Part of the lawsuit was settled and the rest was dismissed. Mr. Hyland, who led North Allegheny Intermediate High School before landing the Plum superintendent job, was not a defendant, but his actions were described in the lawsuit.
The school district’s insurer settled part of the lawsuit out of court, Plum solicitor Bruce Dice said. Terms of the settlement were not publicly available on Wednesday.
According to the lawsuit, a former North Allegheny Intermediate student claimed her classmates bullied, harassed and assaulted her when she was a freshman, and school officials — including Mr. Hyland, then principal — failed to respond appropriately.
Jaimie George, an attorney representing the student, who is identified only as S.K. in the lawsuit, did not respond to a request for comment.
The events described in the suit began in 2009, the evening before the S.K.’s first day of freshman year, when she received threatening texts from a sophomore student as part of a hazing ritual “well known to staff,” according to the lawsuit. Mr. Hyland did not discipline the student, and the harassment continued, the suit says.
Other classmates began to sexually harass S.K., according to the lawsuit. Football players threw bananas at the student and accused her of having a sexually transmitted disease, the complaint says. After each incident, the student reported the bullying to Mr. Hyland and other school officials — but they did not take any disciplinary action, according to the complaint.
During football games, classmates harassed and groped the student — and in one case, threatened to beat her with brass knuckles, according to the lawsuit. Mr. Hyland, who was a football coach at the school, told S.K. to find him on the sideline if the harassment continued, the complaint says.
Classmates also showed up at the student’s job to harass her, and poured liquid on her head in the school hallway, according to the lawsuit. Mr. Hyland confronted the bullies, but never disciplined them, allowing the behavior to escalate, the student claimed in the suit. She said that eventually she tried to kill herself.
A school psychologist suggested S.K. transfer schools, according to the suit. Mr. Hyland offered her a new laptop and the district paid the student’s tuition to attend school elsewhere, the lawsuit says.
Parents at the board meeting on Tuesday questioned Mr. Hyland’s ability to handle cases of bullying and harassment.
In response, Mr. Hyland said Wednesday that he couldn’t comment on specific discipline cases, but that he has always followed laws and policies involving bullying and harassment.
“I will say my concern and commitment to addressing these types of behaviors has been a constant, and will always be a focus at Plum so we can have the most positive learning environment as possible for our students,” he said.
The terms of Mr. Hyland’s Plum contract were not disclosed at the meeting. The five-year agreement includes a starting annual salary of $155,000 and five weeks of vacation. After the first year, Mr. Hyland will be eligible for an annual increase of 2.5 percent each year, topping out at $171,000.
He replaces former superintendent Timothy Glasspool, who left last year, citing an “antagonistic school board.” Mr. Glasspool was placed on paid leave in May 2016 after a grand jury report detailed the findings of a sex-abuse scandal in the district. Three former high school teachers were sentenced to prison after sexual assault convictions involving students.
Under his separation agreement, Mr. Glasspool received his salary of $157,600.
Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or @Mmckinne17.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.