The Pittsburgh Promise scholarship program has once again reduced the maximum amount of money students could receive to assist with costs of college and other higher education.
All graduates of Pittsburgh Public Schools will now be eligible for up to $5,000 annually, down from $7,500, the program announced Monday. It's the second change to the maximum award in about two years, after an announcement in 2015 that the top scholarship would be reduced to $7,500 from $10,000.
The scholarship is not as “generous” as it was before 2016, said Saleem Ghubril, executive director of The Pittsburgh Promise. The changes two years ago were necessary in order to make the program "sustainable" and guarantee that enough funds would be available for students through the Class of 2028. Monday's changes, he said, will help more students access more Promise money.
“I think we’ve found our balance here,” Mr. Ghubril said.
The Promise will no longer use a “sliding scale” of eligibility to determine how much money a student could receive. Previously, only students who had attended a district school since kindergarten — and met certain academic requirements — could receive 100 percent of the scholarship. Students who didn't live in the district as long were eligible for less.
Now, all students who have attended a Pittsburgh school since ninth grade will receive up to $5,000, based on the cost of their college tuition and other expenses and what is not covered by other funding sources. Additionally, the Promise funds can be used to assist with room, board and textbooks — an allowance that was cut two years ago. Each student will also receive a minimum of $1,000, regardless of whether they receive additional financial aid.
The changes will be in place for students of the Class of 2018. Students from previous classes will still receive the same amount based on their eligibility on the sliding scale.
Mr. Ghubril defended the reduction, saying that it actually represents an additional investment of $1.5 million per class from the Promise program and makes it easier for more students to qualify for the larger scholarship amount. But he also acknowledged the challenge it will pose for families of the 30 percent to 35 percent of students who did qualify for the $2,500 more based on the sliding scale.
“In no way do we want our actions to create hardship for anyone and also in no way do we want our actions to come across as ‘we can’t rely on these folks, they keep changing their minds,’” he said.
Ray Micknowski, of Brookline, was upset about the reduction and that the change was announced late in the school year, after his family already went through the financial aid packages for his son's college and filled out the FAFSA form in October.
His son is a senior at City Charter High School and will attend Point Park University next year. He has a second son who will graduate from high school in 2021. Both have been in district schools since kindergarten and would have qualified for the maximum scholarship.
A major reason his family remained in the school district, Mr. Micknowski said, was The Pittsburgh Promise scholarship.
"I’m disappointed that they did this at such a late notification," he said. "They should have given at least the kids entering the college this year the first four years and picked it up after that."
"When (the program) was originally announced, my kids were getting $40,000 for four years," he said. "That is huge. Now they're getting $20,000."
After evaluating the impact of the reductions made in the last round, Mr. Ghubril said data showed that the elimination of the room and board assistance created a “significant hardship” for students, particularly those who are low-income.
Removing the sliding scale will allow the Promise program to distribute funds to more students, but keeping the maximum award at $7,500 would not have been sustainable, Mr. Ghubril said.
“We actually end up putting more money in kids’ hands,” he said.
The change was praised by James Fogarty, executive director of PPS watchdog and educational advocacy group A+ Schools. He said his organization heard anecdotally what the Promise data showed: that more low-income students would benefit if they could use Promise money for room, board and textbooks.
Some parents will be "squeezed" by the reduction in the maximum award amount, he said, but the change makes the scholarship more equitable for all Pittsburgh's students.
"We're definitely supportive of making sure students, especially our most low-income students and those who are first in their families to go to college, have these supports in place," Mr. Fogarty said. "Being able to pay rent and being able to buy books is what keeps kids in school."
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.
Correction, posted Jan. 31, 2018: This story has been updated to show that funds from the Pittsburgh Promise may be used for tuition and other costs of higher education.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.