The North Allegheny school board Wednesday night tabled a vote on starting high school 35 minutes later to give students more time to sleep and deal better with stress.

The proposal would have started both the high schools and middle schools at 8 a.m., which is 35 minutes later than the current high school start time, and 10 minutes earlier than the current middle school start time. Elementary students would start at 9:05 a.m., 5 minutes later than they now do.

Although a majority of board members said that they agree with the science that says that teenagers need more sleep, they want to have more information on the cost of having the three middle schools and two high schools start at the same time. Administrators will do a detailed bus study over the next few months.

Preliminary estimates put the cost at $1 million per year for additional buses.

Advertise with us

A delay will also give administrators time to delve into the amount of homework students receive, which some board members and the student representatives said is more of a factor in student stress than the early start time.

“High school stress is a difficult thing to tackle,” said senior Noah Fenton, the senior high representative to the board. “If we cannot eliminate the things that keep students up at night, we are missing the mark.”

Board member Andy Chomos said he sees three “pillars” in his 11th grade daughter’s lack of sleep – the amount of “busy work” in homework, coaches that don’t end sports practices on time and the early start time. He suggested pushing all start times back by increments, starting with 10 or 15 minutes, and addressing the homework and coaching issues.

Scott Russell noted that college classes do not start until 8 a.m., and many students schedule as few 8 a.m. classes as possible. “There is certainly enough empirical evidence” that kids prefer taking later classes.

Libby Blackburn said the district needs to tackle the homework issue first. “Even if we make the start times later, if we don’t solve the homework and testing, the kids will still be staying up later.”

Advertise with us

She also expressed reservations about having sixth-graders and seniors on the same bus, and said that residents who do not have children in school should have been able to take the survey since adding more buses would affect their taxes.

Before the board announced their intention to table the matter, they heard from nine parents who urged them to approve the later high school start time.

Pamela Behrend said her 17-year-old son falls asleep right after school, and it is hard for her to wake him two hours later. He can’t always get his homework done before he crashes again, she said. “He wants to get all the work done, and he can’t. He’s too tired. He’s cranky. He’s tired, all the time. Please find a way to make it happen, the sooner the better. Please don’t delay. Get it done.”

Elinor Avigad and Jackie Herring both noted that 80 percent of parents who responded to a district survey wanted high school to start later. “That is a clear mandate,” Mrs. Avigad said. “This issue is about our children. Your job as a school board member is to do what is best for our students.”

Diane Collery said that, although her eighth-grader goes to bed at 8:45, he cannot fall asleep before 10:30. “By Friday, he is exhausted. I am terrified about what will happen next year when he gets 7 hours of sleep a night,” she said. “I’m imploring you to make the right decision, make the right choice.”

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.