When James Fogarty looks at Pittsburgh Public Schools, he sees a tale of two districts.

“We see one where attainment is high and education is rigorous, and we see another where students aren't doing well,” said the executive director of A+ Schools, an advocacy group.

Take Langley K-8 and Allegheny K-5, when it comes to reading at grade-level in third grade, widely considered a critical benchmark for future learning.

At Langley, in Sheraden, 17 percent of black students, 36 percent of white students, 43 percent of multiracial students and 25 percent of low-income students met the mark in 2016-17 school year.

Advertise with us

But at Allegheny, a North Side magnet school with a student body much like Langley's, the figures were 72 percent of black students, 90 percent of white students, 91 of multiracial students and 74 percent of economically disadvantaged students, representing “huge, huge improvements” over the previous year.

More stable principal leadership at Allegheny and its magnet status could account partly for the disparity, Mr. Fogarty said. Allegheny and other elementaries like Concord, Dilworth and Fulton, he said, “are going to be our beacons ... our lighthouses to how we can move forward as a district.”

The observations were part of the 13th annual A+Schools' Report to the Community, released Monday. The assessment includes data on schools operated by Pittsburgh Public as well as brick-and-mortar charter schools in the city.

In remarks after the presentation, district Superintendent Anthony Hamlet stressed that the achievement gap “starts at birth” and called for more pre-K education opportunities, also one of Mayor Bill Peduto’s requests for next year’s budget.

“Some of our children are doing well. Some of them are not,” Mr. Hamlet said.

Advertise with us

In Pittsburgh Public Schools overall, the report showed some notable improvements from 2015 to 2016: Third-grade reading scores increased by 8 points overall, and by 12 for black students. The district’s graduation rate increased by 10 percent. Sixty-six percent of seniors got grade-point averages that made them eligible for the Pittsburgh Promise scholarship. Five district schools and two charter schools had achievement gaps of less than 10 percent across several grades on some standardized tests.

Still, significantly more white students (83 percent) qualified for the full Promise scholarship compared with black students (51 percent). While suspensions generally are down, black students are still disproportionately affected by them. And white students comprise 67 percent of those enrolled in the district’s gifted program, while black students make up just 18.5 percent. Enrollment has dropped starkly in four years, too — down 2,437 students since the 2013-14 school year.

A+ Schools mailed the report to 30,000 families with kids enrolled in Pittsburgh Public and put copies at libraries and the offices of local officials.

Sala Udin, an incoming school board member representing District 3, publicly urged advocates “to focus a floodlight” on struggling students, not just on the trends in data.

“We have to be candid,” he said, “that black children are not surviving the public school system.”

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.