A consultant’s recommendations for fixing Pennsylvania’s struggling state university system, released Wednesday, likely will be scrutinized and debated for months and could require a state law change to fully enact.
The result might be a more streamlined State System of Higher Education, whose 14 member universities are better braced for an era of fewer students and lackluster state support.
But those familiar with university system reviews and reorganizations elsewhere say things also could bog down in a tug-of-war between interest groups on and off the campuses, given that the state-owned schools generate not only thousands of graduates each year but sustain thousands of jobs.
As such, some of the loudest voices could be those of politicians hoping to protect communities with campuses.
“One of the things that makes these reorganizations so difficult is that it can create winners and losers,” said Thomas Harnisch, director of state relations and policy analysis for the Washington D.C.-based American Association of State Colleges and Universities. “No legislator wants to be on the losing side of things.”
If one or more schools were to face something approaching consolidation, or in some way be de-emphasized within the system, which ones should they be? What should it look like?
Read More
“This is a process that can take several years,” Mr. Harnisch said. “There has to be a spirit of compromise and a spirit of give and take within the various constituencies.”
That said, State System leaders including Chancellor Frank Brogan have in recent weeks downplayed the likelihood of any university closures, even though they announced the strategic review in January by saying all options were on the table. The consultant recommendations did not include closing any schools.
There is little doubt about what’s at stake. Even after a 12 percent enrollment loss in six years, the campuses collectively enroll 105,000 students, employ 12,500 people and are the least expensive option in the state for obtaining a university education.
The consultant, the National Center for Higher Education Management Systems, has a State System contract of nearly $400,000 to do the work. Since March, a team from the Boulder, Colo., non-profit has visited campuses, speaking to stakeholders and analyzing reams of data.
The 14 system schools include Bloomsburg, California, Cheyney, Clarion, East Stroudsburg, Edinboro, Indiana, Kutztown, Lock Haven, Mansfield, Millersville, Shippensburg, Slippery Rock and West Chester universities of Pennsylvania.
No action on the consultant’s recommendations is expected this week.
That could come later at a scheduled or special board meeting, State System spokesman Kenn Marshall said.
Among the groups watching closely is the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties. Its president, Kenneth Mash, has expressed concerns about the process.
“Every study stands or falls on its own merits,” he said last week. “The faculty had no input into the research design, and there was very limited discussion with constituent groups.
“We will wait and see how the study was conducted and the conclusions they come to. Of course we are apprehensive.”
A recommendation as simple as stepped-up marketing efforts or changes in admissions strategy can be implemented by the campuses themselves. Other recommendations would require a State System board vote.
Still others, like reducing the number of locations, could require an amendment to Act 188, the 1982 state law that turned the 14 former teachers’ colleges into a system.
Closing a public university outright is practically unheard of, Mr. Harnisch said. But there have been consolidations and mergers in states including Georgia and Maine.
Since 2012, the University System of Georgia has reduced its member institutions from 35 to 28. Rather than shut campus locations, it combined administrative operations, yielding $24 million in yearly savings that also enabled better targeted resources for students, said Charles Sutlive, a system spokesman.
For instance, he said consolidating Georgia State University, the system’s largest school, with Georgia Perimeter College, a two-year campus with low graduation rates, has meant more academic support for the latter institution.
“We’re seeing initial signs of increasing graduation rates,” he said.
The University of Maine also combined administrative services and brought its smallest campus under its largest campus, reducing the number of system presidents from seven to six.
In the wake of the recommendations, at least some legislative involvement is expected. The state Senate intends its own review of the State System later this year.
Bill Schackner; bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.