Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School founder Nick Trombetta and his legal team, who have been sparring with the government for weeks following his conspiracy conviction, are now asking a judge to hold the U.S. attorney's office in contempt and pay a fine for filing a document publicly instead of under seal.
But prosecutors say they've followed the same procedure they always do and haven't done anything wrong.
U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti will decide.
In a contentious hearing in December, Mr. Trombetta pleaded guilty to tax conspiracy in connection with siphoning off some $8 million from the cyber school he founded and related corporate entities he created.
He faces up to five years in federal prison at sentencing in March but he's disputing the amount of the loss and the degree of his culpability, and the parties have been bickering back and forth in court filings.
That's typical in high-profile federal court cases, but asking a judge to hold federal prosecutors in contempt for rule violations is not.
In preparation for sentencing, Mr. Trombetta's lawyers filed a document under seal outlining their position on what his sentence should be that included a pre-sentence investigation report. Those reports contain private information and are not public.
But Mr. Trombetta said the government improperly revealed parts of it when it filed its own response on the public docket.
Assistant U.S. Attorney James Wilson said in his most recent filing that the government's filing did not reveal any secret information and that government sentencing position documents are always public in this district.
"Despite [Mr. Trombetta's] vigorous protestations to the contrary, there was simply no disclosure by the government in its pleading of any confidential or otherwise sensitive information and defendant has not proven, nor articulated, any prejudice flowing from the imagined offense," Mr. Wilson wrote.
But Adam Hoffinger, one of Mr. Trombetta's lawyers, said the government has clearly violated federal court rules that require pre-sentence reports to remain confidential.
He said Monday that the U.S. attorney's office has "unilaterally done whatever it pleases" in violation of the rule.
Mr. Hoffinger said that the government is arguing that the rule "doesn't apply because that's just not how they do it around here" and asked for judicial punishment.
"The remedy is contempt," Mr. Hoffinger said.
Mr. Trombetta is set to be sentenced March 3.
His accountant, Neal Prence, was also convicted of tax conspiracy and will be sentenced Feb. 27.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.