The Pittsburgh school board’s primary responsibility is educating children, but at times it also plays the role of developer, and some board members want to have a bigger say in the projects they’re being asked to subsidize.

Last month, four school directors voted against a tax increment financing plan for the Produce Terminal improvement project in the Strip District, three months after the same members nearly blocked a tax break for a separate project.

School board second vice president Moira Kaleida said that among other concerns, members wanted to be consulted “at the beginning of the process. [The] school board is brought to the table when important decisions are already made.”

Past school boards in Pittsburgh have dealt with similar tensions. “The school district has the largest of the three real estate tax shares,” observed district solicitor Ira Weiss, “and has the least to do with developing these plans.”

Advertise with us

The current board also has several members who espouse social justice causes. Ms. Kaleida said several board members have “collective concerns about gentrification” in the city, where some question whether high-end residential developments are crowding out lower-income residents.

“I also want to make sure that we are being responsible with taxpayer money. Do taxpayers want their money going towards corporate tax incentives rather directly into their city and schools?”

City Council and the nine-member school board each must authorize the Urban Redevelopment Authority of Pittsburgh to pursue creation of special tax districts, including TIFs, in which a portion of future tax money is diverted to pay off the cost of infrastructure or other improvements.

Tax revenue from the Produce Terminal and 1600 Smallman Street redevelopments across the street, would be used to fund the tax increment financing plan, estimated at $7.5 million. Improvements would include utilities, new sidewalks, traffic signals, and street crossings to improve safety as well as a Market Square-like public plaza at the end of Smallman near St. Stanislaus Kostka Church.

The school board’s Strip District TIF vote on Nov. 22 ended in a 4-4 tie — meaning that the motion failed. Ms. Kaledia and board president Regina Holley opposed it, along with Kevin Carter and Cynthia Falls. Board member Tom Sumpter was absent and could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

In August, the same four board members voted against a tax break for a 17-story, $106 million residential and retail project in Oakland. Ms. Holley said the proposed rental rates are out of reach for the students it’s designed to appeal to. But with five yes votes, it passed.

URA board member Jim Ferlo, a former city councilman and state senator, said he didn’t oppose consulting with the school board earlier, but said, “I think they need to go back to their mission.”

“No one has done more in terms of creating [housing] opportunities for low-and moderate-income residents than the URA,” he said. But “Despite all this rhetoric about gentrification … some neighborhoods have to be viable enough where the market improves and the tax base improves.”

The URA will try to pitch the Strip District plan at an upcoming school board meeting, but even if members reject it again, a small subsidy could proceed with the backing of the city and county councils, who have yet to vote on the TIF, said Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto. Ms. Falls said she stands by her Strip District vote, but will “keep an open mind” when the URA returns.

Ms. Holley said she supports development in the city, but takes issue with plans that don’t include affordable housing, or that could price out small businesses.

Advertise with us

“Eventually they’re not going to be able to afford the rent that is there,” she said.

Mr. Acklin said a percentage of the terminal building will be committed for small, local businesses, but when Ms. Kaledia raised the issue during an Oct. 5 presentation, URA officials didn’t specifically mention such a plan. Susheela Nemani-Stanger, assistant director of economic development, said the project’s retail mix was unknown.

Mr. Acklin said the URA invites “a robust conversation” with the board. “It’s not, ‘Get out of the way, we know better.’”

He also acknowledged there was some confusion around the URA’s presentation. Mr. Sumpter at the October presentation asked about affordable housing, but a residential component of the project had been dropped months before.

“There was obviously a pretty significant misunderstanding about what this project entailed,” Mr. Acklin said.

Advertise with us

“I was a little surprised they all voted against it,” said school director Lynda Wrenn, who was in favor, saying she thought questions about housing had been clarified.

But as late as Nov. 16, Ms. Holley asked if they could block the TIF if the developer changed gears to build “luxury apartments.” At that same November meeting, Mr. Carter said the Strip District isn’t as “blighted” as other neighborhoods.

“I don’t understand why McCaffery Interests, who typically uses their money to buy old properties and buy luxury apartment complexes in cities that gentrify communities, needs our support,” he said.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.