BELLEFONTE, Pa. — A jury on Thursday ordered Pennsylvania State University to pay $7.3 million to Mike McQueary, who blamed school officials for destroying his life and coaching career after he emerged five years ago as the star witness against Jerry Sandusky and three administrators accused of covering up Sandusky’s sex attacks on boys.
It took four hours for the Centre County panel to find that Penn State officials lied to Mr. McQueary when they promised in 2001 to tell police he had reported seeing Sandusky sexually assault a boy in a campus shower, then damaged his reputation when Sandusky was finally arrested a decade later.
The verdict, after a two-week trial, offered an unusual window into the still searing impact of the infamous serial sex abuse case.
Jurors heard how Mr. McQueary — now jobless, divorced and living with his parents — was targeted by avid Penn State fans who blamed his allegations for damaging the football program’s reputation and for the firing of the school’s iconic head coach, Joe Paterno. And they heard from current and former coaches and administrators who said Mr. McQueary lost his job as an assistant coach in a routine staff shake-up and simply wasn’t good enough to land another one.
As the verdict was read Thursday, the 6-foot-5 former Nittany Lions quarterback showed little emotion. He declined to comment upon leaving the courthouse in Bellefonte.
“What Penn State has done to Mike McQueary is outrageous,” his lawyer, Elliot Strokoff, told jurors during closing arguments earlier in the day. “He should not have been a scapegoat in this matter, and certainly not for five years.”
Read More
Penn State lawyer Nancy Conrad also declined to comment or say whether the school would appeal the verdict. She said Senior Judge Thomas Gavin, who presided over the case, had advised both sides not to make public statements about the case.
Mr. McQueary’s award could grow even larger in the coming weeks. Judge Gavin still has to rule on his whistleblower claim — that Penn State ousted him from his $104,000-a-year assistant coaching job because he spoke out about Sandusky and school officials.
And the jury’s endorsement of his story could also spell trouble for the three of those former officials awaiting trial on child endangerment charges.
Mr. McQueary is expected to play another starring role in their case, revisiting his 2012 turn on the witness stand, when he recounted for Sandusky jurors how he found the defensive coordinator sexually assaulting a boy in a locker room shower and then reported what he saw to Paterno and two Penn State administrators.
Throughout the trial, Penn State lawyers maintained that the school’s decision not to renew Mr. McQueary’s contract that year had nothing to do with his cooperation with the criminal investigation.
“This is not a case about Jerry Sandusky,” Ms. Conrad told the jury. “Any harm that Mike McQueary has suffered ... is the result of his own failures.”
In videotaped testimony shown to the jury, Bill O’Brien — who immediately succeeded Paterno in the head coaching job and has since gone on to lead the Houston Texans — said he came to Penn State in 2012 with a list of his own staff he wanted to bring with him. He never considered Mr. McQueary for a job and his decision had nothing to do with Sandusky.
Matt Rhule, Temple University’s head coach and one of Mr. McQueary’s longtime friends and former teammates, told jurors he deemed Mr. McQueary too unseasoned to offer him a job when he took over the Owls’ program in 2013.
“There was nothing remarkable about Mr. McQueary’s resume,” Ms. Conrad told jurors. “He stayed at one school, under one head coach. He had not developed the contacts or the resume to land a job in this competitive field of professional college football.”
But the jury clearly disagreed.
Among the claims it settled Thursday, the panel found that former university president Graham B. Spanier defamed Mr. McQueary in statements he released in November 2011 in which he publicly expressed support for two colleagues — then-athletic director Tim Curley and vice president Gary Schultz — charged with covering up Sandusky’s crimes. The jury also found that Mr. Curley and Mr. Schultz lied to Mr. McQueary in 2001, when he told them what he had seen and they told him they would take care of it.
Whatever the reason for Mr. McQueary’s dismissal, it became clear through testimony of dozens of witnesses that the impact of the investigation that put Penn State’s football culture under a national microscope continues to ripple five years later.
Judge Gavin said he expects to issue his ruling on Mr. McQueary’s whistleblower claims in the coming weeks.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.