While Plum’s school superintendent has returned to the job, the fate of its high school principal remains unclear, as does the composition of its school board.
Before a 4-3 public vote last month to reinstate superintendent Timothy Glasspool from paid leave in the wake of a highly critical report by a grand jury that investigated a sex-abuse scandal in the district, member Michelle Stepnick resigned.
After stepping down, Ms. Stepnick said she was concerned that some board members were not ready to accept the findings of an independent investigation by the Levin Legal Group, a Montgomery County firm that found no grounds to fire Mr. Glasspool for how he handled various complaints, rumors and allegations of inappropriate behavior by teachers toward students.
“Because it wasn’t what they wanted, they wanted to start another witch hunt,” Ms. Stepnick said recently. “My health can’t take much more. My family can’t take much more of this.”
Since then, however, Ms. Stepnick has had a change of heart and wants her board seat back. She joined nine other people, including Plum activist parent Bill Chapla, in applying for her former position. One of the 10 applicants withdrew his name, citing Ms. Stepnick’s intentions. The applicants have been narrowed to three finalists, including Ms. Stepnick.
“Everyone has a right to change their mind and especially in such a short time,” former candidate Jim Caliendo wrote to the district.
Read More
Board members have interviewed candidates and are expected to vote Tuesday on whether Ms. Stepnick or someone else will fill out her term, which runs until December 2017. Ms. Stepnick, however, said Tuesday that she rescinded her resignation Oct. 10.
“I had the opportunity to rescind. They did not vote or advertise a voting meeting to accept. It was never a vacant seat, according to the Pennsylvania School Boards Association and my own attorney,” Ms. Stepnick said.
Stuart Knade, the association’s senior director of legal services, said he spoke to board secretary Cynthia Vento about Ms. Stepnick but never indicated the position was not vacant.
“The general rule is if you’re past the effective date of your resignation it’s too late to withdraw it [without board consent], and hers was effective immediately,” Mr. Knade said. “When you storm out of a meeting saying, ‘I quit,’ most people would understand that’s effective immediately.”
The newly composed board might be required to take up the issue at some point of what to do with high school principal Ryan Kociela, who was put on paid leave in May along with Mr. Glasspool.
The investigating grand jury, which interviewed dozens of witnesses and pored over thousands of pages of documents, described a culture that allowed sexual relationships to flourish between some male teachers and female students. No criminal charges against officials were recommended.
Some board members who perceived the grand jury report as being one-sided requested that an independent group explore whether Mr. Glasspool or Mr. Kociela violated the state’s Public School Code. The Levin firm has so far billed the school district $27,206 for its work.
To date, the board has not explained why it took up the issue of Mr. Glasspool’s return while leaving Mr. Kociela awaiting a decision.
In addition to Ms. Stepnick’s absence for the vote on reinstating Mr. Glasspool, board member Michele Gallagher was not present. Both women said in interviews they believed their positions on Mr. Glasspool were clear to their colleagues based on a straw poll taken during a closed session, though neither would divulge publicly where they stood. Ms. Gallagher said the board was aware she had schedule conflicts the night of the vote and that she was told the issue would not be on the agenda.
Some are not pleased with how the vote was handled.
“So where were the two missing elected officials?” Plum parent J. Scott Fecsen asked in a letter this week to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. “The most important vote in the history of Plum School District and the community has two no call/no shows from their elected officials. I believe if either of the missing board members take a seat at any future meeting on the school board they owe it to the students, alumni, parents and the rest of the community to explain their position on the return of the superintendent.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.