For presidential debates in the past, Avonworth Middle School teacher Jason Smith made bingo cards for his eighth-grade social studies students, featuring words such as “taxes,” “infrastructure” and “economy.”
But ahead of tonight’s third and final presidential debate between Republican Donald Trump and Democrat Hillary Clinton, bingo isn’t an option. In fact, it’s the first year he hasn’t made it an assignment to watch the debates; he said he’d rather watch them first and pull out the parts most relevant to his class.
“It’s more unpredictable than it has been in the past,” Mr. Smith said. “You just don’t know what they’re going to say, or if it will even be appropriate.”
Mr. Smith’s decision underscores a difficult problem facing educators at all levels: There is simply no playbook for how to teach K-12 students about a presidential race engulfed in such hateful, and sometimes crude, rhetoric. This campaign season — unprecedented in its fervor and hostility — has forced some teachers, who are obligated to remain politically neutral in the classroom, to reconsider their lesson plans.
The discussion comes on the heels of 10 former state and national Teachers of the Year issuing an open letter denouncing Mr. Trump, the Republican nominee, for his “hatred and discrimination,” and recommending that educators abandon their neutrality to teach students about civility and equality.
Mr. Trump’s campaign, fueled by divisive rhetoric about women and minorities and often immersed in scandal, has proved to be especially difficult for teachers.
Read More
“I try to stay right down the middle and present the facts,” said Tyler Bluemling, a social studies teacher at Jefferson Middle School in Mt. Lebanon. “But it’s not my place as a sixth-grade teacher to tell students what sexual assault is, and what happened with Bill Clinton, and what Trump said on the bus.”
In a campaign that has focused more on personality and scandal than discussions of policy, middle school and high school instructors have had to be creative. Mr. Smith had his students list the characteristics they look for in a president, then showed them Mr. Trump’s and Ms. Clinton’s advertisements to compare. Bob Raffaele, a 10th-grade U.S. history teacher at Elizabeth Forward High School, said he tries to “move past the sensationalism to the positions” in an effort to make his students better citizens.
When election questions come up in Darla Gerlach’s fifth-grade social studies class at Shaler Area Middle School, she connects the issues historically and reminds her students to be civil.
“When my students step into the classroom, I try to teach tolerance,” Ms. Gerlach said. “And, at this age level, I’m surprised how cognizant they are of being tolerant of other people’s backgrounds.”
But tolerance has been hard to come by this election, even for the adults. Some teachers say they have noticed that Mr. Trump’s rhetoric — particularly his comments about women, African-Americans, Muslims and Hispanics — has resulted in bullying.
David Broderic, spokesman for the Pennsylvania State Education Association, said the organization’s teachers have “encouraged the political candidates to refrain from using the kind of language that they wouldn’t allow their students to use in the classroom.” He also pointed to an April study from the Southern Poverty Law Center, which suggested that the campaign is stoking fear and anxiety among children of color.
Doug Duda, who teaches sixth-, seventh- and eighth-grade social studies at Manchester Academic Charter Middle School, said his students, who are mostly African-American, have expressed fears about the election. When Mr. Trump said in September that African-American communities are “in the worst shape they’ve ever been,” one of Mr. Duda’s students asked him a startling question.
“‘If he thinks we’ve never had it worse, what does he think about slavery?’” Mr. Duda recalled. “That’s from a seventh-grade student — a 13 year-old.”
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1488.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.