A discovery of language buried in the Woodland Hills School District’s teachers contract is throwing years of benefit payments into question.

The sentence under review dates back to the early 2000s, during a period in which a court decision in Erie asserted that cutting off employer-provider retirement benefits when retirees were eligible for Medicare was age discrimination. That decision led to years of litigation, with the Third Circuit Court of Appeals finally determining in 2007 that health care benefits could indeed legally be curtailed when Medicare went into effect.

But until this year, the Woodland Hills teachers contract still read that “In the event of and at such time as the ERIE COUNTY case and the EEOC guidelines are removed the District’s obligation shall be to provide such coverage from the time of retirement until: eligibility for unreduced … Social Security or a maximum of seven (7) years, whichever period of time is shorter.”

Despite that contract language, and the fact that the Erie case has been settled for nine years, Woodland Hills was still paying its retired teachers for the full seven years, rather than having them switch to Medicare when they became eligible.

Advertise with us

Bill Tomasic, a retired teacher in a different school district who lives in the Woodland Hills School District, discovered the language in the contract earlier this year and informed the district, which quickly revised the contract in the spring to stop the payments for future retirees.

The question is what to do with current retirees who are eligible for Medicare but still in the seven-year period in which they are receiving health care benefits from the district. Woodland Hills initially sent letters this summer informing them that those benefits would be cut off this fall. Upon further review, however, the district decided that the benefits will continue while an outside firm is reviewing the matter.

The hiring of the outside law firm, Campbell Durrant Beatty Palombo & Miller, was approved at a board meeting Sept. 21 at a cost not to exceed $10,000.

“It was a lot more complicated than it appeared at first,” superintendent Alan Johnson said. “The action is on hold — we haven’t terminated anyone’s benefit and we’re not going to do that at this time.”

Currently, 65 employees would be affected if the retirement benefits change, he said, although the number would drop by 20 next year.

Advertise with us

Adam Forgie, president of the Woodland Hills Education Association, said the group “has no comment on the matter other than we are working with the district towards a resolution on the matter.”

Mr. Johnson did not have an estimate for how much money the district would save. “It’s not an easy number to wrap your head around,” he said, noting that factors such as whether the retirees are under family plans or individual plans and slight differences in the contract language affect the cost of benefits. Some retirees also retired under memoranda of understanding specifying that they would receive the full seven years of payments.

Mr. Tomasic, who is a Forest Hills councilman, said he initially received an estimate for the savings of $1.2 million for the current school year if the benefits had been eliminated this fall but then was told that figure would have been lower once the terms of the memoranda were figured in.

The cash-strapped school district has furloughed employees and dipped into reserve funds in recent years, raising its property taxes by nearly 3 mills this year.

Mr. Tomasic has been frustrated both that the language went undetected in the contract for so many years and that the efforts to stop payments haven’t moved faster. “It’s one thing if you’re using the money in a productive way,” he said. “When you’re giving it away and nobody’s going to be held responsible, that’s a travesty.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Johnson noted that the language might not have remained in the contract solely by error. The contract negotiation process can be somewhat murky, he said, and there may have been reasons that it wasn’t removed.

“To somebody who has not been in the process of negotiating a contract it may look like this is just pure unadulterated negligency,” he said, “but that makes an assumption that there weren’t other factors in play.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.