Jerry Sandusky was still awaiting trial when Penn State University alumni set out to install new leadership at their alma mater in early 2012.

A record 86 alumni candidates fought that April for three seats on the school’s board of trustees. Their numbers tumbled to 39 for the next annual contest, slipping to 31 in 2014 and three last year.

Now four candidates — one more than the number of available seats — are campaigning this spring in Penn State’s alumni trustee election. That’s at least a third fewer than in pre-scandal board elections, school records show.

The drop-off worries university supporters who fear a narrower path to the 38-member governing body, which in late 2014 toughened the eligibility rule for alumni candidates. Now they must collect at least 250 nominating signatures, up from 50, as living alumni have soared to more than 645,000.

Advertise with us

“It’s not like a typical governmental election where you can sit outside your local shopping mart and get people to sign a nomination petition. You have to affirmatively know enough alumni out there” to sign, said Ryan Bagwell, a 2002 graduate and former board candidate who lives outside Boston. He called the process “very, very difficult.”

Would-be candidates might see an extra boost — or hurdle — from a dominant alumni interest group, Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, which counts some 50,000 supporters. Since 2013, only contenders with a PS4RS endorsement have won election as alumni trustees. The group formed in 2012.

PG graphic: PSU Board of Trustees

(Click image for larger version)

“Why would you run against somebody when you know you’re going to be defeated?” said Ronald A. Smith, a professor emeritus at the school who wrote the book “Wounded Lions: Joe Paterno, Jerry Sandusky, and the Crises in Penn State Athletics.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Smith said the powerful interest group has built on its early opposition to the board’s November 2011 firing of Mr. Paterno, the iconic head football coach, and to the NCAA sanctions imposed on Penn State after Mr. Sandusky’s conviction in June 2012.

A retired assistant coach under Mr. Paterno, Mr. Sandusky is serving his 30- to 60-year sentence in State Correctional Institution Greene, near Waynesburg. A Centre County jury found him guilty of 45 counts of child sexual abuse, including acts committed on Penn State property.

The case engulfed the university and toppled the presidency of longtime executive Graham Spanier, who is fighting criminal charges that include a failure to report suspected abuse. Two other former administrators are battling similar charges.

Prosecutors did not charge Mr. Paterno, who died Jan. 22, 2012, but a separate review accepted by the Penn State board several months later flayed both the late coach and administrators over their handling of Mr. Sandusky. Lead reviewer Louis Freeh, a former FBI director, said Mr. Paterno and the other men failed ”to protect against a child sexual predator harming children for over a decade.”

In part, the findings identified a “closed culture” in athletics and “a resistance to outside perspectives” at Penn State. That helped fuel the NCAA sanctions and outrage among Paterno loyalists, some of whom argue the Freeh report does not support its own conclusions. Many of those detractors found a political home in PS4RS.

Advertise with us

Mr. Freeh’s group did not immediately respond last week to messages from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

“We’re looking for candidates who have truth and transparency in their platform,” said Maribeth Roman Schmidt, the PS4RS executive director. She said past trustees “turned their back” on integrity and accountability that should underpin Penn State.

To win a PS4RS endorsement, Ms. Schmidt said, alumni trustee candidates should agree that the Freeh report is fatally flawed. Likewise, the group believes the board mistreated the Paternos in the past and needs to “mend fences” with the family.

“What we’re expecting is the fortitude to stand up and admit” a mistake, Ms. Schmidt said. “That’s what will heal everybody to move on.”

But she said it’s more important to PS4RS that “we have a mission to improve our university for the benefit of the current and future students. When you look at the qualifications of the trustees we’ve been able to put in over the last four years, we’re making good on that mission.”

Advertise with us

The three incumbent alumni trustees seeking re-election this month carry endorsements from PS4RS. Edward “Ted” Brown, Barbara Doran and Bill Oldsey are among seven board members who sued Penn State last year to gain access to source documents underlying the Freeh report.

They’re conducting a confidential review of those materials. Mr. Oldsey would not comment on when they might finish the effort but said he wants to debunk the report. Like others linked to PS4RS, he attributed the decline in alumni trustee candidates to general satisfaction with newer board members, at least in part.

“I would tell you that, by and large, the alumni base at Penn State is very pleased with the job that the incumbent, alumni-elected trustees are doing. So their attitude right now is, ‘Stay the course,’ ” said Mr. Oldsey, a 1976 graduate who is moving from Basking Ridge, N.J., to the State College area.

He said the alumni trustees’ interests go beyond the scandal fallout, citing his focus on controlling administrative costs. Mr. Brown, a 1968 graduate, said he has worked to tame tuition rates, and Ms. Doran, in an email message to some constituents, noted an “overriding responsibility” to improve academic quality and push affordability. She graduated in 1975.

Mr. Paterno’s widow, Sue, and one of their sons, Jay, endorsed the three incumbents last week. Still, critics contend the alumni-picked trustees have spent too much time fretting about football and recognition for Mr. Paterno.

Advertise with us

“Their emphasis has to do with things that really aren’t primary. When the board can’t coalesce around the important issues, I think that creates problems,” said 1958 graduate Tom Hollander of Thornburg, a former Penn State Alumni Association president.

He lamented the dip in alumni candidates, although he couldn’t say whether fewer choices would damage the university.

“I’m always in favor of diversity and a wide panel of interests being reflected in a governing body,” Mr. Hollander said.

Alumni-elected trustees serve unpaid, three-year terms and account for about a quarter of the board seats. Online ballots in the current race are due by 9 a.m. May 5, with results to be announced at the board meeting that week. Alumni may request ballots through the board’s website.

To Dan Cocco, a 2008 graduate who is challenging incumbents this month, Penn State “can learn from the events of 2011” but cannot change them. His ideas include strengthening financial aid and maintaining students’ “competitive edge.”

Advertise with us

“I think there’s not enough focus on the issues that matter most to students and most of the alumni,” said Mr. Cocco, who lives in Hoboken, N.J. He isn’t running to review Mr. Freeh’s findings, although he agrees with his opponents that Penn State should honor the late Mr. Paterno, he said.

He also hopes to show that alumni trustee candidates can win without a PS4RS endorsement. Mr. Bagwell, the earlier candidate, said Mr. Cocco might “unlock that lock.”

“He has a chance to do that. But even if he wins, the alumni trustees are still in the minority. They will still lack the votes to get their agenda accomplished easily,” Mr. Bagwell said. “I don’t think the outcome will mean much to the running of the university as a whole.”

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625. Twitter: asmeltz.