Carol A. Brown grew up the daughter of a barber in Fairchance, near Uniontown. Her family scrimped and saved for her to go to college, where she majored in education and went on to a long career as an elementary school teacher and guidance counselor.

To honor her memory after she died in 2013, her husband, Marvin, and sons created a scholarship seeking to help a student with some of Ms. Brown’s qualities — someone committed to majoring in education at Virginia Tech, where Ms. Brown did her graduate work.

They worked with the Pittsburgh Foundation to get the scholarship off the ground for 2014, offering as much as $5,000 per year, and waited for their first applicant.

Two years later, they’re still waiting.

Advertise with us

“We feel that there’s a need out there,” Marvin Brown said. “It just isn’t working.”

And they’re not the only ones. About $1.5 million in scholarships from The Pittsburgh Foundation went unawarded last year — money that the foundation and its donors would much prefer to be giving away. The foundation gave out 662 scholarships totaling $2.19 million in 2015, but had the potential to award $3.6 million if every scholarship had been filled.

The Pittsburgh Foundation cites a combination of reasons — overly specific or outdated scholarship requirements, overworked guidance counselors and unconfident and unmotivated students. The end result is not enough applicants.

“Most often it’s really about the robustness of the applicant pool,” said Susan Acito, grants manager at the Pittsburgh Foundation. “We don’t have enough applicants to make an award to make it an open and transparent process.”

Unawarded scholarship money is not generally a problem for larger scholarships at the national level, said Amy Weinstein, executive director of the National Scholarship Providers Association. But it can be an issue for community foundations that award local scholarships, such as the Pittsburgh Foundation, she said.

Advertise with us

One issue is the specificity of the scholarship, at the donor’s request. Donors often want to honor the memory of a deceased loved one by helping someone exactly like them — but those people aren’t always easy to find.

“Some people will ask for pretty specific majors, like a musician that specializes in the harp — the pool might only have one kid who’s already on a full scholarship,” said Lindsay Aroesty, director of donor services at the Pittsburgh Foundation. “I had a donor that wanted all the students to be of Russian descent, and it was hard for us to come up with students of Russian descent.”

One scholarship administered by the Pittsburgh Foundation is for direct relatives of African-American former employees of Volkswagen of America in New Stanton. Another one is for students of Serbian background majoring in science. Yet another gives preference to those who are either blind or studying the arts.

One scholarship, the Marc Obniski Memorial Scholarship Fund, has been offered every year to a financially needy senior at Highlands High School planning to major in engineering. Some years there are five students who could qualify, said Ms. Aroesty, and some years there are zero. To draw more applicants, the scholarship was broadened this year to also include students studying engineering at Robert Morris University.

Mr. Brown is also seeking to expand his scholarship, looking to include education majors at other schools where his family has ties, such as Penn State University, California University and West Virginia University.

Advertise with us

Occasionally, scholarships need to be adjusted as they age out of relevance. The 14th Quartermaster/​Operation Desert Storm Scholarship Fund originally only applied to education for the surviving children and spouses of the 13 soldiers from Greensburg who died in an attack in Kuwait in 1991.

Over the years, as their educational needs diminished, the scholarship was broadened to all children of veterans or current Army members in Westmoreland County.

Other scholarships are fairly broad, however, and still don’t attract applicants.

One program offers an $8,500 stipend — including $1,500 in living expenses — for a 10-week internship in a Washington, D.C., legislative office. Despite being open to all undergraduate students from Western Pennsylvania, the James G. Fulton/​J. Steele Gow Fellows Program only got three applicants this year, all of whom were funded.

A scholarship that provides a $5,000 stipend to a first-year resident at the West Penn Allegheny Health System didn’t get a single applicant last year (applicants for the Claire B. Morrison Fund must have also graduated from medical school in Allegheny County). By contrast, a parallel scholarship that funds a first-year resident at UPMC got 13 applicants.

Advertise with us

Foundation personnel speculate that students aren’t finding out about the scholarships, perhaps because high school guidance counselors and college financial aid counselors are overworked or have other priorities.

“We have very high applicant pools within certain school districts,” Ms. Acito said. “Those are the districts where the guidance counselors are working with students.”

The Pittsburgh Foundation has a list of scholarships with deadlines this spring and summer on its website (http://pittsburghfoundation.org/scholarships-open). Though some deadlines have already passed, most are still accepting applications.

The foundation is also hoping to improve its search function to enable students to find scholarships easier.

For Gordon Giffin, it’s a phenomenon that’s completely puzzling. Mr. Giffin began a $2,000 renewable rotary club scholarship in 1995 when he was president of the Carnegie-Collier Rotary Club.

Advertise with us

In recent years, the scholarship added a separate fund of $1,000 per year for a student who lives in the Carlynton or Chartiers Valley school district and attends a vocational school.

And for the past three years, not a single student has applied for the vocational award — despite Mr. Giffin’s efforts to reach out to the schools, have booster clubs make announcements and even have the mayor include information in an email blast that Collier sends out for fish fries.

He wonders whether students are just lazy, whether they don’t understand the importance of a dollar or whether the schools aren’t passing along information.

“We just shook our head,” he said, “and finally started saying, ‘Doggone, this is nuts.’ ”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.