The superintendent of the Connellsville Area School District took issue with some parts of a state audit that found the district used up its fund balance by pouring millions into its Career and Technical Center and chose its top administrator largely out of public view.

Phil Martell emphasized that the facility wasn’t the sole reason behind the district’s depleted rainy-day account, citing other factors including its pension liability, several years without a property tax increase, and an enrollment decline in a large rural school system that faces more challenges than its neighbors.

“There are a number of things to blame, not just the CTC,” he said. “[The center] is never going to be self-sufficient. But we have to generate more revenue.”

The performance audit, which generally covered the period from June 29, 2012, through Jan. 30, 2016, “raised concerns about the district’s long-term financial stability and leadership ability,” Auditor General Eugene DePasquale said in a statement.

Advertise with us

His criticisms focused mainly on two areas: the technical center and the way the district chose its superintendent.

Some of the financial pressures facing Connellsville Area, Mr. DePasquale said, can be found in many other school systems, and he noted that the district applied best practices “in the areas of academics, finance, governance and school safety.” But his office said the district “set in motion a unique financial drain” when it established its own career and technical center years ago, calling it “the largest financial strain on the district’s finances.”

Costing millions each year to operate, the center educates less than 5 percent of the district’s students but helped deplete the district’s fund balance, despite seven consecutive years in which its general fund operations showed a surplus.

Between 2008 and 2014, the district’s fund balance first increased to $14 million, but then declined to $3 million — leaving less than financial industry guidelines say should be kept for unforeseen expenses.

The balance was poised to move into negative territory, the audit found.

Advertise with us

Between 2008 and 2014, the district transferred $20.5 million from the fund balance to the Career Technical Center and an additional $28.8 million for debt service, some of it for the center.

Connellsville is the only school district in Fayette County that has its own center, according to the audit. The other five districts send students to a countywide vocational school and pay a per-student fee.

When he started working with Connellsville Area as business manager in April, Mr. Martell said he moved to furlough 40 teachers and support staff and cut part of the transportation budget, resulting in a $5 million savings. He has asked the school board to increase millage to the Act 1 index and has applied for exceptions to that, enabling the school system to raise taxes at a higher-than-normal level.

Now, he said, officials are looking at “realigning” the district and consolidating services and schools.

“If we don’t do that for [2017-18], we cannot survive,” he said.

Advertise with us

And to lift the center’s burden off the district, Mr. Martell said he has a plan to upgrade the facility over three years through grants and investments from outside organizations and by drawing students from other districts on a tuition basis.

Mr. DePasquale also took issue with the changeover in the superintendent’s office and the way the district hired Mr. Martell, who was acting Connellsville Area superintendent from November until Jan. 27.

“In the last six years, Connellsville has had five superintendents, three of whom were ‘acting,’” Mr. DePasquale said. “When our audit team spoke with district administration on Jan. 20, they assured our auditors they were conducting a nationwide search for a new superintendent.”

“However,” Mr. DePasquale continued, “just days later, the board hired the acting superintendent — who had been the business manager with the district only five months before he was made acting superintendent — for the full-time superintendent spot under a five-year contract without publicly advertising that the vote would occur at the Jan. 27 meeting.”

Mr. Martell said he specifically asked that auditors note the “revolving door” of district leaders in their report. “I thought it was important. We agree that stability has been an issue.”

Advertise with us

As for the superintendent search, he said, “Let me make it really clear: That is an inaccurate statement by the auditor general. This district never authorized a nationwide search.”

Mr. Martell said the district advertised the superintendent position, and only he and one other person applied. He acknowledged that the item about his hiring was added to the agenda at and not before the Jan. 27 meeting, but he said there was opportunity for public comment before the vote.

He said the board underwent the same process with the previous acting superintendent, but Mr. DePasquale didn’t point that out.

“If he has such a big issue with that, then why not identify both [examples]?” he said, adding, “If someone had an issue with me, they had plenty of time” to address it before the meeting.

Mr. DePasquale said his office also has turned over a copy of the audit to the Fayette County District Attorney’s office to see whether one aspect of the findings — what the auditor general said was improper awarding of overtime and compensatory time by a former superintendent — warrants further investigation.

Advertise with us

Regarding that matter, District Attorney Richard Bower would say only that his office is “looking into investigating the findings in the audit.”

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 and on Twitter @molly_born. Bill Schackner contributed.