WASHINGTON — The U.S. Senate on Wednesday put individual states back at the head of the class when it comes to evaluating students, teachers, schools and school districts.
In an 85-12 vote, the Senate dismantled former President George W. Bush’s signature No Child Left Behind Act and transferred control of testing and assessment to the states.
The 2002 law had long been unpopular with teachers, parents, students and school board members across the country who said it was unworkable.
Wednesday’s legislation, which President Barack Obama is expected to sign today, prohibits the federal government from telling states and local districts how to assess performance. States and local districts now will set their own goals, design their own measures of achievement and decide for themselves how to turn around struggling schools.
The legislation retains a key feature of No Child: the federally mandated statewide reading and math exams in grades three to eight and one such test in high school. But it would encourage states to limit the time students spend on testing, and it would diminish the high stakes associated with these exams for underperforming schools.
There was strong bipartisan support for the legislation, which had been endorsed by the nation’s governors, teachers unions, chief school officers and administrators.
Read More
Three of the presidential candidates missed the Senate vote — Republican Sens. Ted Cruz of Texas and Marco Rubio of Florida and Vermont Independent Bernie Sanders. Pennsylvania’s two senators voted in favor.
Testing, although important, had become excessive, said Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa. The old law created an incentive for educators to teach toward the test rather than to help children truly master content, he said.
Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., said the reforms provide guidance in broad categories without being a “one-size-fits-all, formulaic Washington prescriptive program.”
“It gives these schools and school districts more control of their own destiny,” he said.
Pennsylvania Education Secretary Pedro Rivera said it now will be easier for Pennsylvania school districts to align their standards with skills needed in college and in careers.
“We can be much more holistic in how we’re building accountability around schools,” Mr. Rivera said. “We’ll still have the same rigorous standards, but now we’ll have many more ways to measure school success.”
The legislation includes a measure aimed at keeping child predators from victimizing students at school. Sponsored by Mr. Toomey and Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., the measure forbids school administrators from knowingly recommending a suspected child abuser for a job in another district.
The practice is known as “passing the trash,” and engaging in it now can cost school districts federal education funding because of the Toomey-Manchin measure. Several states already have such laws, but they apply only to intrastate job changes.
“Whatever legislation is passed in Pennsylvania can’t protect Pennsylvania from another state sending these monsters into Pennsylvania, and that’s why we needed federal legislation,” Mr. Toomey said.
He and Mr. Manchin also pressed for making background checks more stringent and for expanding them to include all school personnel who have contact with children. Their efforts were blocked by anti-federalist colleagues who said background checks are best legislated by state governments.
Mr. Casey also lost a battle to include in the bill funding for pre-kindergarten programs for 3 million of the country’s most impoverished children. Working with two colleagues, however, he was able to get support for more competitive grants for states to improve coordination, quality and access for early childhood education.
Mr. Rivera said Pennsylvania districts have waiting lists of parents who want to enroll their 3- and 4-year-olds. The grants would allow Pennsylvania to accommodate more of them and to improve the quality of programs, he said.
Republican Sen. Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, who leads the Senate Education Committee, called the legislation a “Christmas present” for 50 million children nationwide.
Mr. Alexander, a former U.S. education secretary, said he hoped Mr. Obama “will wrap a big red bow around it ... and send it to the children and the 3.4 million teachers who are looking forward to it.”
Mr. Alexander was a chief author of the bill, along with Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash.
Ms. Murray, a former preschool teacher, said work must now begin in “our schools, in our communities, in our states,” to find ways to make sure all students achieve. “We expect them to live up to that, and that’s the promise of this bill.”
States will still be required to intervene in the lowest-performing 5 percent of schools, in high schools with high dropout rates and in schools with stubborn achievement gaps — something Democrats had pushed.
The measure will end the waivers the Obama administration has given to more than 40 states, including Pennsylvania. The exemptions had been granted around the more onerous parts of No Child when it became clear that requirements such as having all students proficient in reading and math by 2014 would not be met.
Changes to funding formulas under the legislation mean that Pennsylvania will lose about $25 million for teacher training over the next six years but will gain much more — $53 million — for technology assistance, Advanced Placement courses, safety initiatives and more. Under the previous funding system, Pennsylvania received $7.5 million a year for those kinds of programs, according to the state Department of Education.
No Child Left Behind passed with broad support in Congress 14 years ago but was later criticized for a heavy-handed federal approach that imposed sanctions when schools came up short — leading teachers, administrators and others to worry that the high stakes associated with the tests were creating a culture of over-testing and detracting from the learning environment.
The Associated Press contributed. Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com, 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.