A former South Allegheny middle school teacher, charged in two criminal cases for allegedly having inappropriate relationships with two students, pleaded guilty in one case Monday to institutional sexual assault and endangering the welfare of children.
Cole McLaughlin, 23, of Belle Vernon will be sentenced by Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel on that case on Feb. 16. The plea agreement calls for a period of probation to be set by the court and a 25-year Megan’s Law registration.
He is scheduled for trial in the second case on Feb. 8.
Mr. McLaughlin, who taught social studies, told county investigators during an interview in April when the allegations were raised that he kissed a 12-year-old student twice and hugged her several times. Her father went to police after he discovered messages in the girl’s phone in which Mr. McLaughlin referred to her as “angel,” and “babygirl.”
The two communicated through the mobile phone applications Snapchat and Trivia Crack.
The second case involves a 17-year-old student who claimed that Mr. McLaughlin sent her photographs of himself naked.
During a motion hearing following the plea, Mr. McLaughlin’s defense attorney attempted to have his client’s statement to police, as well as evidence discovered on his cell phone, thrown out.
John E. Egers Jr. told Judge McDaniel that his client, who went to the Allegheny County police headquarters willingly, did not feel free to leave and felt compelled to cooperate with the police.
“I went to the police to try to explain my side of things,” Mr. McLaughlin testified. “I didn’t expect to be arrested. I didn’t expect to sit in jail for seven days.
“I never even got detention in school.”
He acknowledged signing a form giving consent to the police to access his phone but said he was told it was just a standard form.
“But how it was portrayed... I know I signed it.”
In addition, Mr. McLaughlin offered to unlock the phone for the detectives.
Allegheny County detective Michael Opferman said that Mr. McLaughlin was free to leave the interview, but he said he did not think that was the case. He testified that the officers told him not to use his phone in the interview room repeatedly — even when his parents kept calling.
Judge McDaniel, who refused to suppress the evidence, said there is a constitutional right for a defendant to speak to an attorney — not to use a cell phone or call his parents.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.