A new survey of presidential earnings at private colleges finds that pay increases nationally have accelerated, and in Western Pennsylvania, that was especially true for Esther Barazzone, longtime leader of Chatham University: Her total compensation more than doubled.

Ms. Barazzone earned $902,611, up from $362,606 the previous year, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education, which released its survey results Sunday evening.

Ms. Barazzone’s total pay, half of it in deferred compensation intended to keep her at Chatham through retirement age, was not enough to bring her close to the highest paid nationally. Her rank was 46th out of 558 campus leaders surveyed, The Chronicle reported.

But she was the top earner among private college presidents in Western Pennsylvania during the 2013 calendar year covered by the survey, the most current available for national comparisons.

Advertise with us

Nationwide, that year’s median compensation of $436,429 represented a 5.6 percent increase, compared with 2.5 percent the previous year. But the number of presidents surpassing $1 million in earnings actually slipped by four to 32. A total of 77 have eclipsed the $1 million mark since 2008, The Chronicle reported.

Topping the survey was Columbia University president Lee Bollinger, with $4,615,230 in total compensation, followed by University of Pennsylvania president Amy Gutmann, second in the survey with total compensation of $3,065,746.

Both leaders derived most of their income from pay other than base salary. It is a pattern typical of those who soar in the survey one year due to bonuses, deferred earnings or other one-time payments including those received when they leave office, said Sandhya Kambhampati, data base reporter at The Chronicle and survey author.

Big executive paychecks are fodder for critics, especially when schools struggle financially, but trustees and compensation consultants argue that presidents have round-the-clock responsibilities and can be hard to retain.

PG graphic: Presidential pay

Advertise with us

(Click image for larger version)

Schools “will highlight respective accomplishments to justify the pay,” Ms. Kambhampati said. “At the end of the day, it’s up to the institution to think about how much it can afford to pay.”

Ms. Barazzone took office in 1992, back when Chatham was an all-female institution. In June, as it prepared to become fully coed, she announced plans to retire in 2016 after nearly a quarter-century in the job.

The more than doubling of her earnings in 2013 resulted largely from the second of two big payouts in a multiyear deferred compensation package approved by Chatham trustees in 2006, board chairwoman Jennifer Potter said.

The package, which Ms. Barazzone would have forfeited had she left early, was intended to “address deficiencies in her retirement funding from early in her presidency, when Chatham was unable to provide retirement contributions commensurate with other institutions of our size,” Ms. Potter said in a prepared statement.

Advertise with us

Ms. Potter cited a fourfold increase in enrollment to 2,100 students, $150 million in fundraising and other growth during Ms. Barazzone’s tenure, including addition of the Eden Hall campus.

“For the past 24 years, Dr. Barazzone has led Chatham through a period of profound transformation and success,” Ms. Potter said. “We are thankful for her leadership … .”

In addition to deferred compensation of more than $460,000, Ms. Barazzone received $416,839 in base pay in 2013 — 37 percent more than the previous year.

In 2011, the initial payout from Ms. Barazzone’s deferred compensation package and from other earnings — when combined with her $283,839 base pay that year — boosted her total earnings to $1.8 million, The Chronicle reported at the time.

Ms. Barazzone was traveling and unavailable for comment, school spokesman Bill Campbell said.

Advertise with us

The Chronicle’s look at pay at 497 institutions included some whose presidents began or ended their tenure during 2013. Last year, it modified its methodology to count as earnings only the part of deferred compensation actually received during the survey period.

Pay for other Western Pennsylvania private campus presidents ranged from Jared Cohon, Carnegie Mellon University’s president at that time, at $871,145, including $550,736 in base pay and $69,250 in bonus pay; to Kenneth Smith of Geneva College at $234,641, including $190,079 in base pay. Mr. Cohon left office in July 2013; Mr. Smith stepped down earlier this year.

Subra Suresh, who became CMU’s president on July 1, 2013, received $676,899 in total compensation, including base pay of $353,264 and $186,637 in bonus pay, The Chronicle reported. The Chronicle does a separate survey of public college and university president pay in May.

The data comes from IRS form 990 filings as well as information filed with the U.S. Department of Education.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.