Three Democratic senators are “profoundly dissatisfied” with education and justice officials for arranging a settlement last month that required Pittsburgh-based Education Management Corp. to pay about $96 million in fines, just 1 percent of the federal student loan money it was accused of using to defraud students and taxpayers.
In a letter dated Nov. 30, the senators — Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass.; Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn.; and Dick Durbin, D-Ill. — asked the U.S. Department of Education and U.S. Department of Justice to use the full weight of their authority to recover student loan debt from the Downtown for-profit education company, which operates the Art Institutes, Argosy, Brown Mackie and South University.
Whistleblowers filed a lawsuit in 2007 alleging a systemic culture of deceptive recruiting tactics, including paying recruiters bonuses and perks based on how many students they enrolled. Incentive-based practices, illegal under federal law, pushed students into programs where they lacked the necessary skills to succeed, the letter stated.
When the Justice Department joined the lawsuit in 2011, it called into question $11 billion in federal student aid the company received from 2003 to 2011. Attorneys general from 39 states had also launched investigations into EDMC for possible fraud.
In concurrent settlements last month, the state attorneys general won $102.8 million in private institutional loan forgiveness for 80,000 former students, including $4 million for 2,683 former students in Pennsylvania.
In its separate settlement, the Justice Department won a $95.5 million civil penalty — but nothing in federal student loan debt.
Read More
In announcing the federal deal on Nov. 16, Education Secretary Arne Duncan said EDMC’s actions were “not a misrepresentation to students. It was breaking the law and lying to us.” But the senators’ letter calls Mr. Duncan’s thinking “logically absurd” and said it “makes little sense in the context of the allegations against EDMC.”
“EDMC cannot be guilty of lying to federal officials about recruiting students unlawfully unless EDMC actually recruited students unlawfully,” the senators wrote. “Federal regulators appear to have obtained nothing for students, leaving defrauded students holding the bag for billions of dollars in federal student loans they incurred after being illegally pressured to enroll.”
The letter also expresses frustration that prosecutors could not extract an admission of wrongdoing from the company, just two months after the Justice Department announced a policy to specifically bring more individual accountability from allegations of wrongdoing at the corporate level.
An EDMC spokesman declined to comment on the senators’ letter. Justice Department officials did not respond to a request for comment.
Dorie Nolt, Education Department press secretary, said in a statement that Mr. Duncan “correctly stated that fraud against the United States was the focus of the government’s intervention” in the whistleblower case and that the settlement does not provide proof of wrongdoing against individual students.
If evidence is presented, she said, Mr. Duncan is prepared to act on it.
Ms. Nolt noted the settlement contained the largest civil penalty ever assessed against an education company in a case in which the government joins citizens in litigation. The settlement also requires EDMC to reform its practices, including recording all calls and chats between recruiters and prospective students.
“Attorneys for the education and justice departments negotiated aggressively in this case,” she said.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.