West Jefferson Hills school board faced controversy Tuesday on three fronts — an appointment to fill a board vacancy, a vote on the construction of the new Thomas Jefferson High School, and last month’s return of the high school girls basketball coach.

After 17-year board member David Graham resigned, effective immediately, for business and personal reasons, board President Anthony Angotti recommended that board member Darlene Schreiber be appointed to fill the remaining two years of his term.

Mrs. Schreiber lost her bid for re-election in this month’s election. She had to resign her seat to become eligible for the appointment and was then appointed to the board by a 5-2 vote, with Mr. Angotti, Alan Caponi, John Hosmer, Anna Lilley and Carolyn Bourgeois voting yes.

Mr. Agnotti’s recommendation of Mrs. Schreiber for the seat sparked outrage among some of the roughly 200 people at the meeting.

Advertise with us

Ryan Pierce of Jefferson Hills called it an “underhanded move” and said that residents should be allowed to apply and be interviewed.

“This is deceitful and not right,” Mimi Haley of Pleasant Hills told the board.

Newly elected board member Jill Bertini of Jefferson Hills said such tactics were what led to no incumbents being re-elected.

“Voters had enough of this circus,” she said.

The board voted 5-4 to advertise a request for proposals for the $100 million high school construction project and include in the request a project labor agreement, known as a PLA.

Advertise with us

The PLA requires that 80 percent of a company’s workers must be members of a union and the remaining 20 percent must join a union for the length of the project.

Voting in favor were Mr. Angotti, Alan Caponi, John Hosmer, Anna Lilley and Carolyn Bourgeois.

In May, the board had voted to include a PLA whenever that project was eventually bid.

Before Tuesday’s vote, the board heard public comments on the inclusion of a PLA.

Pro-union speakers said including the agreement would mean higher quality work on time and on budget.

Advertise with us

Those opposed to its inclusion said it would drive up costs, exclude local competitors and not guarantee high quality work.

Keith Impink of Greensburg, president of Westmoreland Electric, said he would not bid on work that includes a project labor agreement because he wants to use his own employees.

After the meeting, R. Pete Gum, president of the Western Pennsylvania Chapter of the Associated Builders and Contractors Inc., said that 80.8 percent of tradesmen in Pennsylvania are nonunion.

“So [the school board] discriminated against over 80 percent of tradesmen because they chose not to belong to a union,” he said.

Eight members of the high school girls basketball team came to the meeting in support of coach Phil Shar, who was suspended in September and then returned to his position last month.

Advertise with us

However, 10 girls who refuse to play basketball for Mr. Shar also came to the meeting and reiterated their complaints that he was verbally and emotionally abusive to players. Some of the parents of the 10 girls asked that his suspension be reinstated.

Mr. Shar was suspended with pay pending an investigation of the complaints by some parents and players. Then, in a surprise motion that was not on the printed agenda for the Oct. 27 meeting, the board voted 5-4 to return Mr. Shar to his position.

In response to the parents’ request Tuesday that Mr. Shar’s suspension be reinstated, solicitor Lisa Colautti said that, under Robert's Rules of Order, only a board member who voted to return Mr. Shar to the coaching position, or who was absent for that vote, may make a motion to reconsider.

With the five new board members coming aboard next month, they would fall into the ''absent'' category and the motion could be made, she said.

“I hope that the new board will listen to the girls. They all want to get back on the court together,” parent Bonnie Brock said after the meeting.

Margaret Smykla, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com