Megan Batykefer didn’t know that having sex with an 18-year-old student was a crime.
That wasn’t an excuse, her defense attorney said at her sentencing hearing on Tuesday, but a reason why he believed the North Allegheny High School rowing coach ought to get probation instead of going to jail
“I don’t think this person would be standing before you if she knew it was against the law,” said attorney Christopher Urbano.
But Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski, who found Batykefer guilty in August of one count of institutional sexual assault following a non-jury trial, said probation was not enough.
A felony-level offense, the judge said, calls for more than probation or house arrest.
“In plain English, you just cannot do this and not expect to go to jail,” Judge Borkowski said.
He ordered Batykefer, who has already lost her teaching certification and career, to serve eight to 23 months in jail to be followed by three years’ probation, as well as register as a sex offender for 25 years.
The judge allowed Batykefer, 32, of Coraopolis to remain free on bond while her defense attorney files an appeal with the state Superior Court challenging the constitutionality of the criminal charge. Mr. Urbano argued earlier in the case that the statute is vague and overbroad, particularly given that the victim was 18.
But the judge wrote in finding Batykefer guilty that the legislation was written to prohibit sex between a teacher and student regardless of age. Further, it was designed to protect students who might lack maturity to make good decisions.
“The statute appropriately places that responsibility entirely and squarely on the shoulders of the person, who by maturity and professional position, is responsible for avoiding such activity,” he said.
Prosecutors said Batykefer’s relationship with the student occurred in April, May and June 2014.
In asking for probation, Mr. Urbano said his client cooperated with law enforcement and has a history of mental health issues. In addition, he said, the victim said he did not want Batykefer to go to jail. Mr. Urbano called only one witness on his client’s behalf — her father, Gary Batykefer.
He described the year since charges were filed against his daughter as “very tough.”
“I just hope this court could show some empathy in the sentencing process,” he said. “Incarceration and labeling will not help Megan.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.