Former Penn Hills school district business manager Richard Liberto filed suit on Friday against the Penn Hills school district, school superintendent Nancy Hines and school board president Denise Graham-Shealey.

Mr. Liberto says he was put on paid leave in March and later suspended without pay as retaliation for reporting theft by deception of time records for one school district employee and the wasteful use of school district resources by Ms. Graham-Shealey. According to Mr. Liberto’s lawsuit, his suspension violates the state’s Whistleblower Act and he is requesting restoration of back wages, compensatory damages, lawyer’s fees and all relief available under the law.

Mr. Liberto says that deceptive record keeping practices allowed a school district employee to retain vacation days by using sick days to take Fridays off in the summer. The district’s contract with employees allows secretaries to take Fridays either by working additional hours Monday through Thursday or by using vacation days. It does not provide using sick days as an option for Friday leave.

“There is absolutely and unequivocally no truth to these allegations,” Ms. Hines said in a statement. “We believe this disgruntled employee who was accustomed to working in an environment with no checks and balances is retaliating against the administration's attempt to impose a higher standard. It is shocking and disheartening to see someone resort to this level of misrepresentation.”

Advertise with us

In September 2014, Robin Galko, a secretary, reported the improper practice to Mr. Liberto who claims he took the matter to Thomas Washington, who was the superintendent at the time. Although no disciplinary action was taken against the employee, Ms. Galko was suspended without pay. She filed a whistleblower lawsuit in January.

In addition, Mr. Liberto claims that Ms. Graham-Shealey requested and got the use of a school bus to transport a single Penn Hills student to a location for which the district already provided bus service. Mr. Liberto claims this practice was unnecessary and cost the school district $40,000. Ms. Graham-Shealey has denied that the use of the bus was unnecessary.

“We will not respond to any allegations regarding students having documented disabilities; however, the suggestion that a Board member would need to arrange related services for any such child makes no sense. We have a whole department devoted to ensuring we are in legal compliance with plans devised to support students with disabilities,” Ms. Graham-Shealey said in a statement.

Mr. Liberto also claims that school officials attempted to create false reasons to fire him and instead attributed his suspension to poor job performance.

Tim Means, freelance writer suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.