The board of the Pittsburgh Public Schools has taken its first steps to conduct a national search to replace superintendent Linda Lane by hiring a New York City-based consulting firm to take the helm.
The move to hire a consulting firm without a request for proposals from other potential candidates raises questions about the amount of input and participation the public will have in the hiring decision.
At the end of a public voting meeting last week, school director Regina Holley made a motion to hire the Perkins Consulting Group — headed by Brian Perkins, director of the Urban Education Leadership Program at Columbia University’s Teachers College — at a cost not to exceed $100,000.
The measure passed with affirmative votes by Ms. Holley and school directors Terry Kennedy, Carolyn Klug, Sylvia Wilson and board president Thomas Sumpter. School director Cynthia Falls dissented and directors Mark Brentley, Sherry Hazuda and William Isler abstained.
The move attracted little attention at a meeting that featured a lengthy discussion and vote on the Pittsburgh district’s plan to absorb more than 200 Wilkinsburg secondary students at Westinghouse 6-12 in the fall of 2016.
Ms. Falls, when reached after the meeting for comment on her dissenting vote, referred all questions to Mr. Sumpter, who did not respond to multiple phone messages.
Read More
District solicitor Ira Weiss said a contract with Mr. Perkins has not yet been finalized. While the funding source to pay for the consulting group was not outlined in the board resolution, Mr. Weiss said it will be paid for with district funds.
The scope of services to be provided by the Perkins firm, outlined in the board resolution, include meetings with “city and business leaders and supporters,” town hall meetings and a website and toll-free phone line for “community input.”
Ms. Holley said she and Mr. Sumpter met Mr. Perkins at a conference for the Council of Urban Boards of Education in July and were “impressed with his credentials.” When Mrs. Lane announced in September her plans to retire in June, Ms. Holley recommended Mr. Perkins as a consultant in the superintendent search.
She said other school directors suggested different consulting firms, but “this was the one the board ended up agreeing upon,” she said.
“Personally, it was important to me to find someone who has extensive experience working with urban school districts,” Ms. Holley said.
Last month, the A+ Schools advocacy group held a community session to discuss best practices for the superintendent search process.
About 120 people attended, including former school board members Alex Matthews and Patrick Dowd and people who were involved in the hiring processes for top employees in the administration of Mayor Bill Peduto. That process, backed by local foundations, involved significant participation from local community leaders on selection committees.
From that meeting, the group released three distinct points: that the board has a difficult job in selecting a new superintendent; stakeholder input is essential; and that the process matters.
After the hiring of Perkins Consulting group, A+ spokesman James Fogarty said members of his organization had some concerns about the move.
“We are glad to see they are moving ahead with the process, but we have questions,” Mr. Fogarty said. “We’re not sure how Mr. Perkins was selected and whether other firms were considered.”
Mr. Brentley said he abstained because he did not have enough information about the consulting firm leading into the vote, and he questioned why the board did not wait to include the three new board members who take office in December in the decision.
“If you’re constantly telling the public, ‘Look at me, we’re transparent and we’re honest’ and then you put a resolution on the agenda at the last minute that’s so vague with no details, no contract, nothing ... that’s very misleading,” Mr. Brentley said Tuesday. “It’s not a clean process and starting off this entire search on a bad foot.”
Staff writer Mary Niederberger contributed. Clarece Polke: cpolke@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1889 or on Twitter @clarepolke.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.