Propel Montour charter school’s interest in expanding to serve high school students has neighboring Sto-Rox School District seeking potential solutions to the impact charter schools are having on the district now and may have in the future.
Although in litigation, the Pennsylvania Charter Appeal Board’s approval of another Propel charter school to be created within district confines is a grave concern to officials of the low-income district.
An Oct. 22 public discussion on the topic netted several suggestions, including a greater focus on middle and high school students, restructuring grade configurations, and using existing space to create in-house alternative education models that could be opened to other districts on a tuition basis.
“Fifty years ago Sto-Rox became a model of school mergers; today we can become the model of how to beat the charters. We just need to do what we’ve always done: provide the students of McKees Rocks and Stowe Township with a world-class education,” said Robert Spehar, high school teacher and teachers union president, speaking on behalf of the Sto-Rox Education Association.
Discussion occurred mainly between school faculty and officials with an occasional recommendation offered from among about 30 audience members.
Suggestions were far-reaching.
Superintendent Terry DeCarbo resurrected a plan first presented in 2012 by then-superintendent Michael Panza to create an in-house elementary academy system that would call for a longer school year, longer school days and additional languages and content.
Essentially, what charter schools are already doing, Mr. DeCarbo said.
His take on the program called for the focus to be shifted to the middle school.
Elementary principal Rachel Gray was concerned that focusing on secondary grades would hurt programming already in place for grades K-5 and suggested taking a look at grade configurations. Audience members suggested moving grade 8 or grades 7 and 8 to the high school where there is available classroom space.
“I don’t want the elementary school forgotten. It has more students than the other two schools combined,” said director Patrick F. Dorrenbacher.
A concept proposed by the teachers last spring was reintroduced by Mr. Spehar. It calls for the creation of in-house alternative education and charter schools to be housed in district buildings and staffed by current teachers and support staff. Eventually, these schools could be opened to other districts for tuition, he said.
“Everything changes. No matter why, there is a great mountain before us: We need to add additional programs and opportunities all while using our limited resources as wisely as we can. The wisest way to use those resources is to look within and together climb that mountain,” Mr. Spehar said.
Clearly, something has to be done. The annual increase in number of students leaving the Sto-Rox district to join Allegheny County charters is having a tremendous negative financial impact on the district budget, he said.
“There is no question, we are hemorrhaging students to the charter schools,” Mr. DeCarbo said.
The district has an enrollment of about 1,400. Sto-Rox pays for 234 students to attend six of Propel’s 10 charter locations. There are 168 Sto-Rox students enrolled at Propel Montour and another 49 at Propel Northside. Additionally, the district pays for students to attend cyber and charter schools through other charter organizations.
Financially, the district is on shaky footing and even if it were to receive all of funding expected from the state this year, the district still would barely be able to balance its budget, Mr. DeCarbo said.
“That’s the reality of Sto-Rox,” he said.
By the end of September, Mr. DeCarbo said Sto-Rox had spent approximately $426,000 to send students to charter schools. Additionally, about $30,000 in transportation costs were incurred.
“Fifty years ago people said that Sto-Rox wouldn’t last. Those people were wrong then and the people who say it today are wrong now. Sto-Rox ain’t goin’ anywhere — so long as we start working on this together right now,” Mr. Spehar said.
Sonja Reis, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.