Over Wolf administration objections, Pennsylvania’s state-owned universities Thursday approved four additional campus pricing experiments that supporters say help schools better align tuition and fees with market conditions but opponents say make schools less affordable.
The pilot programs for California University of Pennsylvania and Edinboro, Mansfield and Shippensburg universities were authorized at a State System of Higher Education board of governors meeting, during which some members spoke with growing concern about deteriorating finances at a number of the 14 campuses.
They cited pressures from double-digit enrollment losses and recent state aid cuts, to fixed costs such as pensions and — as of the July 1 start of the fiscal year — an overdue state appropriation.
The pilots approved, effective next fall, include:

(Click image for larger version)
■ A request by Cal U to lift a cap on the per-credit academic support fee, meaning that even students considered full time with at least 12 credits would continue to be charged at a rate of $31.30-per-credit for in-state residents and $46.90 for out-of-state residents;
■ A request by Edinboro to charge an additional $30-per-credit for students enrolled in high-demand, high-cost science, technology, engineering and math and health courses, except for courses required for nursing students, who already pay a higher fee;
■ A request by Mansfield to begin charging all undergraduate students tuition on a per-credit basis and freezing that rate for eight consecutive fall and spring semesters for students currently enrolled;
■ A request by Shippensburg to replace the flat full-time tuition rate for in-state undergraduate students with a per-credit charge, phasing the full per-credit price in over four years.
The four pilot programs collectively are projected to generate about $9 million in new revenue and are among roughly two dozen pilot programs the board approved this year and last.
Some have effectively lowered rates to attract groups such as military veterans and out-of-state students — both seen as key to rebuilding enrollments. Others, like the four pilots approved Thursday, involve higher prices.
Voting against the pilots at Thursday’s meeting in Harrisburg was Sarah Galbally, Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf’s appointed representative to the board. Wolf spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said it’s wrong to increase prices just after the system board in July approved a 3.5 percent in-state tuition increase, to $7,060, for the 2015-16 school year and given the governor’s proposals for increases in education funding.
Mr. Sheridan said the Mansfield and Shippensburg per-credit pilots were being advanced, despite limited information on how a similar program has affected Millersville University. He said data on the other pilot programs needed to be examined before pushing forward.
“We’re running into the danger of pricing Pennsylvanians out of our public universities,” he said.
But state Rep. Matthew Baker, R-Tioga, a board member supporting the pilots, called them essential. He said it’s no secret Cheyney University is in financial distress, but finances at other schools are deteriorating, too.
He said his understanding was that Mansfield officials “were coming close to running out of reserves after this fiscal year.” He said Cal U and Clarion, among others, also bear watching.
“There are several other universities that are going to be running through their reserves very soon,” he said.
The system board sets tuition and a technology fee for the 14 universities. Individual campuses set additional fees, and the price flexibility pilots give those schools an even greater say in what students on their campuses pay to attend.
Ken Mash, a professor and president of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties, told the board that whether or not it chooses to call them “pilots” doesn’t matter. “What we're talking about are tuition and fee increases,” he said.
Board members in December are expected to review data on how the pilots so far have impacted students.
Also Thursday, the board set its state appropriation request for 2016-17 at $521.2 million and approved offering schools up to $200 million in cash advances as needed to help pay bills if the Commonwealth budget deadlock continues.
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.