Joe Giansante didn’t become a teacher until he was 45 years old.

“I thought I could save the world,” said Mr. Giansante, who holds a bachelor’s degree in administration management science and math from Carnegie Mellon University and worked as a computer programmer, systems analyst, computer consultant and head hunter.

Now at the age of 56, after eight years of teaching math in Pittsburgh Public Schools, he is fighting to save his career and his name while administrators are battling to try to dismiss a teacher they view as ineffective.

Mr. Giansante, who had received satisfactory ratings for six years at what was then Pittsburgh Westinghouse High School in Homewood, received unsatisfactory ratings in both of his years teaching at Pittsburgh Brashear High School in Beechview. The second one in 2012-13 triggered the process for dismissal.

Advertise with us

Few teachers fight as hard or as publicly to try to save their jobs as Mr. Giansante. He spoke three times at board public hearings and, in a rare move, opened his tenure dismissal hearing to the public.

And while administrators spend time extensively documenting teacher evaluations in general, district staff members usually don’t have to put in so much time and effort to dismiss a tenured teacher as in this case.

Most teachers who receive an unsatisfactory rating leave. Over the past four years in the school district, 157 teachers have received at least one unsatisfactory rating. Of them, 106 have left, and 51 remain employed by the district.

A second consecutive unsatisfactory rating for a tenured teacher triggers the process for dismissal. Of the 44 who received a second unsatisfactory rating, only one continues to teach, the only one to prevail in a binding arbitration hearing. Five others took their cases to binding arbitration and lost, resulting in their being dismissed by the school board. The others left.

Mr. Giansante thought he would stand a better chance with a board hearing. He is the only teacher in at least four years — and likely much longer — to choose such a hearing. Nina Esposito-Visgitis, president of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers, said the union typically favors a binding arbitration hearing because it is conducted by a neutral party. The board hearing process has more avenues of appeal for both the district and the teacher.

Advertise with us

His board hearing was attended by one board member, Cynthia Falls, and produced thousands of pages of transcripts and exhibits.

After about two years of waiting and procedural wrangling, Mr. Giansante’s board hearing took place over five days, beginning in April and ending in July. Final briefs were filed last month, and board members received copies of the transcript and exhibits in mid-September. The board could vote as soon as this month’s meeting.

What makes for ‘satisfactory’?

Mr. Giansante isn’t accused of any gross misconduct. This is a question of quality.

The basic question is this: Is he a satisfactory teacher?

Advertise with us

Mr. Giansante said he has taken his case this far because “I can’t let something go, not when I know I’m right. I know I’m one of the best teachers in that district. To be called unsatisfactory is completely ridiculous. … You can call me average … but unsatisfactory? That’s a guy who doesn’t try. Kids who know nothing in class.”

The reason Mr. Giansante believes he is one of the best teachers in the district is he has a particularly high VAM score. VAM — which stands for “Value-Added Measurement” — is the district’s own numerical calculation of a teacher’s effectiveness.

Based on test scores, VAM uses a statistical formula to consider how much students learn over a school year in an effort to attribute that learning to a teacher. A high VAM score means that the students in a teacher’s class learned more than expected. On its website, the district describes it as a “rigorous statistical method of measurement.”

In Pennsylvania, the state requires school districts to include a form of VAM — typically the state’s formula known as PVAAS — as part of teacher evaluations.

But VAM also is controversial. Ms. Esposito-Visgitis considers it just one of many measurements. “A lot of experts across the country question VAM,” she said. “To a lot of people, VAM is a black box.”

Advertise with us

On a scale of 1 to 100, Mr. Giansante got an overall score above 90 in each of 2011-12 and 2012-13, including an overall VAM of 99 on one report he provided. The district does not have an average teacher figure for Brashear, but it has the average for the Brashear building, which is a separate calculation making a comparison to other schools in the state. The average for the Brashear building was 12 for 2011-12 and 2012-13 combined.

While VAM now is part of a teacher’s rating, it was not when Mr. Giansante was rated in 2011-12 and 2012-13. Instead, the ratings were based fully on principal observation. School solicitor Ira Weiss, serving as hearing officer, declined to allow Mr. Giansante’s attorney James Carney to present the VAM scores because they were not part of the district performance evaluation process for the years in question.

Mr. Carney challenged that in the final brief, calling the VAM scores “the only objective evidence with respect to the impact of his teaching on the learning done by his students.”

Admitted into evidence were the results of the Tripod student survey, now used in formal evaluations but also not a part of the evaluation at the time. Mr. Giansante provided reports showing his Tripod scores were generally higher than the Brashear average although not as dramatically so as the VAM scores. His Tripod scores were based on a single survey that he said was assigned to be given in fall 2012 to a class that had only nine students in attendance because some others were on a field trip.

In the hearings, three co-principals — Angel Washington, Kimberly Safran and John Vater — and the math curriculum supervisor at the time, Jeffrey Ziegler, presented their evidence. It was based largely on multiple documented observations of his classes. Criticisms ranged from not following the required pedagogy to failing to always stand at the classroom door between classes.

Advertise with us

Ms. Washington, who now is principal of Pittsburgh Carrick High School — said Mr. Giansante used too much “IRE” — which stands for initiate, respond and evaluate — rather than using higher-level questions that require more critical thinking.

Ms. Washington criticized the student groupings in the classroom, saying he was not culturally responsive and said too many students were off task. She said he did not follow the expected phases of a lesson. She recounted efforts made to provide him with help, from taking him to another school to observe a teacher to encouraging him to meet with a math coach.

Ms. Safran said his classroom was “often characterized by students who act inappropriately and who are disengaged from learning.”

From his observations, Mr. Ziegler said he didn’t think Mr. Giansante did adequate planning and counted few students actively working.

Documenting the positives

Advertise with us

In his testimony, Mr. Giasante noted a “shout out” commendation given to him in a school assembly and signed by four Brashear students. He said other teachers who were part of his professional learning community had given him positive feedback. He contended he did teach from the curriculum, noting the tests his students did well on were based on the curriculum.

He acknowledged one class observed in December 2011 was “chaotic,” but he considered another in January 2012 exemplary.

Two former students testified on his behalf, saying other teachers faced some similar issues, such as disruptive students in class, as Mr. Giansante. A former colleague at Westinghouse, Craig Jackson, who was a math coach and shared his room, complimented his teaching.

Mr. Giansante left Westinghouse when it was to offer single-gender classes in fall 2011 and transferred to Brashear, where many teachers had been hand-selected for new initiatives. While he earned satisfactory ratings at Westinghouse, Paul Lalley, attorney for the administration in the hearings, noted two letters in his file.

Early in his time at Brashear, Mr. Giansante said he persistently and unsuccessfully sought to get an interactive whiteboard, which he had used at Westinghouse. He was criticized for using a packet he developed over the summer for use during a period in which he said his textbooks were on back order.

Advertise with us

Mr. Giansante contended his teaching improved even though repeated observation reports said “no improvement.”

Of the meeting in which he received a second unsatisfactory rating in May 2013, he said, “It kinda made me sick to my stomach. There was no anger. I was just crushed.”

Mr. Giansante, who is the father of two grown children and a 2-year-old and the grandfather of three, said the last two years have been “nothing short of hell. I’ve got a family to support.”

Mr. Giansante of Pleasant Hills has been teaching math part-time at Community College of Allegheny County since 2007 and is teaching two courses there this fall. He also has done odd jobs and is trying to build a business selling annuities and life insurance.

“I used to make a lot of money in my head hunting, consulting business,” he said. “I wanted to make a difference. I know that might sound a little sappy. … A friend said, ‘You were born to teach.’ ”

Advertise with us

He had enjoyed coaching kids in sports, and he had done some informal math tutoring. He decided to go back to school, earning a master’s degree in teaching from California University of Pennsylvania in 2004.

He student-taught in South Park, became certified in 2004 and started out as a one-year substitute in Keystone Oaks. Pittsburgh Public Schools offered him a job, and he started teaching at then Pittsburgh Westinghouse High School in Homewood in 2005.

When he’s in Homewood at Community College of Allegheny County, he said, he’ll sometimes hear someone call “Mr. G,” and it will be one of the students he taught at Westinghouse.

“I think I’ve done a lot of good for kids,” he said.

Education writer Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com