When Vanessa McCarthy-Johnson graduated from Wilkinsburg High School in 1984, she had multiple college acceptance letters under her belt, including a few from Ivy League schools.
The Wilkinsburg Borough Council president marched as a majorette in the band and joined the ski club. The school also offered a range of challenging honors classes and extracurricular activities, including an active athletic and drama department. Her sister, with whom she lived, moved into the district because of the educational opportunities there, she said.
Those days, she said, are gone.
Wilkinsburg School District and Pittsburgh Public Schools unveiled Wednesday an “internal working group” to study the possibility of sending Wilkinsburg students in grades 7-12 to city schools on a tuition basis as soon as fall 2016. Under the plan, Wilkinsburg would maintain its identity and student test scores would be tracked separately from those at PPS.
“I got accepted into every college I applied to because of the strong educational foundation I received at the high school,” Ms. McCarthy-Johnson said. “But now things have changed, and sometimes you have to make difficult decisions. This is a huge undertaking … the school board has worked so hard to right a lot of wrongs.”
Wilkinsburg student Makayla Wilson, 14, said she would stay within the district if given a choice. The eighth-grader said she has made too many memories playing clarinet in the school band and performing in school concerts to want to leave.
Read More
“I don’t want to leave other people and leave the school,” she said.
Her classmate Jimmy Marsh, 14, has been in the district for a few years now and is ready to see something different after watching the student population dwindle.
“This school is small now,” he said. “I just want to go to a bigger school, see more things, see what it’s like [elsewhere].”
The district’s tiny student body and limited financial resources have had an impact on academic offerings and extracurricular activities for students. The high school had the lowest School Performance Profile score in the state in 2013-14. SPP scores are largely based on results from state standardized tests as well as some other factors.
In March, the district canceled the baseball season for the second consecutive year because it did not have enough students to field a team. The district offers no Advanced Placement courses.
However, Wilkinsburg Education Association president Mike Evans said the alternative options for students within Pittsburgh Public Schools aren’t significantly better. Wilkinsburg’s student body is 90 percent black and more than 75 percent of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
“I don’t think they are doing much better for their African-American and poor students, and those are the students in Wilkinsburg who use our schools,” he said. “We need to find a way to bring diversity back to our schools — commitment, AP classes, things that foster learning and achievement. Abandoning our schools and farming the kids out to the city isn’t the way to do it.”
Carey Harris, executive director of A+ Schools, an education advocacy group in the city, cited schools including Pittsburgh Allderdice 9-12 in Squirrel Hill and Pittsburgh Obama 6-12 in East Liberty as schools with strong academic outcomes for minority students.
“The conversation should not just be where do we have space — this isn’t a hotel; it’s an educational endeavor,” she said. “We need to make sure we’re providing them something better.”
Pittsburgh Westinghouse 6-12 in Homewood and Pittsburgh Allderdice are less than 4 miles from the Wilkinsburg middle/high school building on Wallace Avenue.
Although Allderdice boasts almost 20 AP classes, Westinghouse offers only a handful. In 2013-14, only 7 percent of black 11th-grade students tested proficient or advanced in math, nearly the same as the 6 percent who tested proficient or advanced in Wilkinsburg.
In reading, however, 17 percent of black 11th-graders at Westinghouse tested proficient or advanced, compared with 7 percent in Wilkinsburg. At Allderdice, 61 percent of the black 11th-graders tested proficient in reading and 44 percent in math.
By the time Amma Ababio, 18, graduated from Allderdice in the class of 2015, she had taken almost a dozen AP classes and participated in activities, including the school musical and TeenBloc of A+ Schools.
The Harvard University-bound student said her “champions” at school, including a team of counselors and mentors, helped prepare her for the Ivy League. However, the serious talks between Wilkinsburg and Pittsburgh are premature until the district can resolve issues of racial equity and access to resources for minority students already enrolled there, she said.
“These issues definitely need to be addressed before the students come,” she said. “I don’t like this idea of building a plane while you’re flying it, because it’s so easy in the meantime for students, a lot of whom are minorities, to fall through the cracks.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.