The Baldwin-Whitehall School District has taken six years to make recommended changes to its financial controls to prevent embezzlement, has no documentation for some $45,000 in charges made on district procurement cards and recently raised taxes despite a healthy reserve fund.

Those details were revealed in a performance audit report released Monday by state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale.

Other findings include the board’s November 2013 appointment of school director Martin Schmotzer to the $120,000-a-year position of supervisor of special projects for the school board and special assistant to the superintendent violated the Public School Code. Mr DePasquale said board members can resign and go to work directly only for a teaching job in their school district, according to the code. Mr. Schmotzer resigned about a month after his appointment in response to intense public pressure.

The audit also revealed that the district will likely have to return $343,061 in tuition payments that the district received from the state Department of Education. Auditors said the district had inadequate documentation on 28 institutionalized and foster children who attend the district of about 4,400 students. The district’s response was that not all of the children were improperly documented.

Advertise with us

Superintendent Randal Lutz could not be reached for comment nor could board president Roy Rosing.

Mr. DePasquale in his report said turnover in the administration may have contributed to a lack of oversight and the inability to implement recommendations of past audits. Since July 2008, the district has had two superintendents, four business managers and seven treasurers.

He said the board “frequently exercised poor governance” by creating the job for Mr. Schmotzer in violation of the school code and by failing to implement recommendations that were repeatedly made in audits over the course of four years. Each audit reported that the district did not present its financial statements in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Practices as directed by the state.

Specifically, he pointed to fiscal controls recommended after a forensic audit performed in 2009 by Horovitz Rudoy & Roteman that determined $298,556 was missing from three district accounts — payroll, athletic and the district’s construction fund.

A police investigation at the time found that “a person of interest” in the missing funds was district secretary Linda McWreath, who was found dead in the Youghiogheny River in May 2009. Allegheny County Police at the time said the death was a suspected suicide.

Advertise with us

Lawrence Korchnak, who was Baldwin-Whitehall superintendent at the time, said the district would “implement new procedures and processes to ensure that this will not happen again.” But, Mr. DePasquale said they were not implemented until recently.

As for the $45,000 in procurement card purchases, Mr. DePasquale said it’s impossible to tell if they were appropriate purchases because there are no documents or receipts. “They could have been legitimate or they might have been a Ferrari, he said.

The report said the district had at least four accounts with credit limits ranging from $10,000 to $500,000. In its response, the district said it has reduced its use of procurement cards, limiting them to the offices of superintendent, business manager and director of operations.

Mr. DePasquale said districts do not need to use procurement or credit cards, but rather should have a list of approved vendors and pay for goods and services via invoices.

The auditor general said the appointment of Mr. Schmotzer to a high-paid administrative position violated not only the school code, but also the public trust since the job was not publicly advertised and was created and filled at the same meeting.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Schmotzer took umbrage to that remark. He said the position to which he was appointed was created specifically by the board to address the issues in past audits. His job responsibilities included “being up at central administration on a regular basis overlooking the administration.” He said the position was created in response to past audit recommendations.

Earlier this month, the state Ethics Commission released a 32-page report in which it said Mr. Schmotzer orchestrated his own appointment and that through a consent agreement he would repay the $4,568 he received while on the job.

Mary Niederberger; 412-263-1590; mniederberger@post-gazette.com.