Talks have reached a stalemate between officials at Sto-Rox and Propel Schools Foundation over plans for a K-12 charter school for about 800 students.
The groups have met for about six months to discuss what Sto-Rox officials hoped would result in partnerships that would allow the district to remain viable.
Sto-Rox directors voted in July 2011 and June 2012 to deny Propel’s charter applications to operate Propel West. The Pennsylvania Charter Appeal Board in September overruled Sto-Rox, but the district has appealed that decision.
Acting Superintendent Terry DeCarbo said Sto-Rox has had “deep conversations” with Propel but has been unsuccessful. He said in recent weeks he felt “stonewalled” and Patrick F. Dorrenbacher, board president, cited concerns of inflexibility with meeting during evening hours, when members of the school board could be available.
“We don’t have a say at the table now. That’s what is heart-wrenching,” Mr. DeCarbo said. “Our goal was to save Sto-Rox.”
Jeremy Resnick, Propel Schools executive director and founder, said he recently received a letter from the district stating they were “no longer interested in meeting with us.” He indicated his group would be willing to continue talks.
Propel has stated it has a lease-agreement option to acquire vacant land between Hillcrest and Elizabeth avenues in Stowe where a new school could be built, but has entertained the possibility of sharing school space with Sto-Rox. Plans now call for a 2016-17 opening date for Propel West.
Sto-Rox officials said negotiations included forming partnerships for advanced placement and honors-level programs, as well as for students with difficulties; setting enrollment windows; and the possibility of sharing of facilities.
“We could have made Propel look a whole lot better if this would have worked out,” Mr. Dorrenbacher said.
Placing a limit on the number of additional Sto-Rox students who could attend Propel West to 200, with a limit of 50 per year was a key consideration. If Propel West were to recruit 200 more students or possibly more during its first year of operation “it would buckle our knees,” Mr. DeCarbo said.
Sto-Rox has 266 students attending five of the 10 Pittsburgh-area Propel Charter Schools. A majority of these students attend Propel Montour, which opened in 2007 in Kennedy and is home to 410 students in grades K-8. Enrollment at Sto-Rox is 1,400.
The cost for these 266 students to attend a Propel school during the month of April was more than $298,000, Mr. DeCarbo said.
In 2013-14, the district said it paid $1.596 million in subsidy deductions for tuition payments to Propel. The Sto-Rox operating budget that year was $23.149 million. The district’s 2014-15 budget is $22.727 million.
The mission of the Propel system is to provide parents with “equality and fairness” and the choices they are looking for, Mr. Resnick said.
“If people with money have access to it, then families without money should have access, too. Parents pay their taxes so their children can get a quality education. Propel makes it possible for the tax payers to provide that quality education,” Mr. Resnick said.
Many Sto-Rox parents have been requesting an alternative to the current public education system.
“[Standardized tests] show that kids from communities like Sto-Rox can perform,” said Mr. Resnick, referring to the results shown by students from McKees Rocks and Stowe who attend Propel Montour. “It’s not just another school, it’s another great school.”
Propel and Sto-Rox have been meeting for four years. The most recent round of talks stalled after Propel School’s enrollment office reached out to Sto-Rox parents of students at Propel Montour to gauge interest in a program where they would send their children to a K-4 center in a secured area inside Sto-Rox High School.
The questionnaire, provided by phone and by email, became public when these parents began discussing it on social media.
“Progress was being made and the bottom came out when [news of] this survey went online,” Mr. DeCarbo said.
This proposal alarmed Sto-Rox teachers and staff who asked directors at school board meetings to refrain from sharing facilities and instead work on bettering educational offerings for students.
“We were not trying to throw the baby out with the bathwater,” said Mr. DeCarbo, indicating education of students and retention of jobs were first and foremost.
The goal was to “sustain Sto-Rox and keep the Sto-Rox brand. We understand the parents want choice, we weren’t going to forgo our missions and goals because of a charter school coming in.”
Sto-Rox Solicitor Ira Weiss said in order to have a viable public school, you cannot have “a charter school as envisioned by Propel” in the district.
Sonja Reis, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.