The North Allegheny school board has awarded more than $22 million in contracts to renovate over the next two summers Bradford Woods and Marshall elementary schools and Marshall Middle School.
Although board members unanimously approved the base bids April 22, members turned down four alternate bids — one for Bradford Woods and three for Marshall Middle School. All three schools were either built or last renovated in the early 1990s.
“I think, generally speaking, when this district has taken on renovation projects, what we’ve tried to do is not the glitzy thing but the serviceable thing,” board member Maureen Grosheider said. “For the most part, these buildings will not be touched again in a major way for 20 years.”
Most of the alternates that were eliminated had to do with aesthetics.
“Curb appeal is not as important,” board member Kevin Mahler said. “Educational improvements are nice, but we are being asked to do a lot of other things for education, such as technology.”
In upcoming months, the board is expected to vote on a bond issue to finance the construction. How that additional debt will affect next year’s budget, which currently has an $8 million deficit, still must be addressed.
“We have to make the decision tonight, but it is a very uncomfortable decision because of the projected budget deficit,” Mrs. Grosheider said.
The successful bidders for Bradford Woods Elementary were: R.A. Glancy & Sons, general contractor, $2.43 million; East West Manufacturing, heating, ventilation and air conditioning, $1.64 million; Allegheny City Electric, $632,470; and East End Plumbing, $229,500.
Board members voted 6-3 to eliminate an addition to the art room, which would have cost $109,250. A majority voted to replace gutters and downspouts, enlarge a second-floor restroom to make it comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act, and repair the sidewalk.
Adding in the 7 percent contingency for emergencies and “soft costs,” such as fees and financing costs, the total Bradford Woods project is $6 million, about $500,000 under budget, said Robert Gaertner, director of facilities, who made a two-hour presentation.
Contracts totaling $6.48 million — approximately $384,500 under budget — were awarded for Marshall Elementary to Gurtner Construction, general contractor, $2.6 million; Lugalia Mechanical, HVAC, $2.29 million; Merit Electric Group, $1.3 million; and AMB, plumbing, $224,600.
All alternates were approved, including a student drop-off and pickup area by the cafeteria for $309,400. With the contingency and soft costs, the Marshall Elementary project is expected to cost $8.4 million.
Contracts for the $11.3 million work on Marshall Middle, which are $1.8 million under budget, were awarded to Glancy, general contractor, $2.36 million base bid, plus $560,570 in alternates; Rennick Brothers, HVAC, $3.3 million; Right Electric, $1.9 million; and Enders Plumbing, $243,500.
Breckenridge Kitchen Equipment received the contracts to provide food service equipment for all three schools. The company’s bids were $109,495 for Bradford Woods, $150,168 for Marshall Elementary and $329,153 for Marshall Middle.
Three alternates for the middle school were not approved, including a platform below the gym ceiling for storage. Board members approved an alternate for a fourth music room, which will be a bump-out on the auditorium side of the building.
During the votes on each of the 23 alternates, Mrs. Grosheider reminded her colleagues that cutting corners doesn’t always serve the district. She noted the 1995 renovation of the intermediate high school.
“As soon as the building was done, you were looking at it and saying, 'Well, that was one of the dumbest decisions we ever made.’ ”
Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.